Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 morgan samuels:
re: About Russian winter


"To underestimate the influence of winter is the same as to disregard the tough defense of the Russian soldier."

Given that weather conditions during WW II were so important, and also given that the Germans chose to ignore several key aspects of those effects when planning to invade Russia, it stands to reason that the Germans seriously bungled their preinvasion planning.

The only thing I can think of is that they thought they could knock out the Soviets in spite of the weather. The Germans knew darn well what was going to happen during the rains and during the winter. They must have been *so* sure of themselves to invade in the face of such problems.

It seems to me that the Soviets were well aware of those very same conditions and were prepared to deal with them. They even fielded large cavalry units right up to the end of the war because horses are more mobile than vehicles during certain weather and in certain terrain.

The Germas screwed up and the Soviets made them pay for it. Both fought in identical conditions. One side was ready, the other BY CHOICE was not.

All too often the tone of western histories is that the weather and mud "saved" the Soviets, as if they were incapable of doing it themselves. That does not wash. The weather came as no suprise. If it so happens that the Soviets made better use of conditions then that just points out good flexability on the Soviets part.

Fri Apr 21 10:24:30 2000


Back to page 

 HERALD About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
Henkster Western History = German History (Apr, 11)
Greg Leon Guerrero re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
George Hogg re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Valera Potapov re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
HERALD re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Valera Potapov re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
Trapo re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
Nick re: Horses? "General MUD!! (Apr, 11)
Max re: Horses?  (Apr, 11)
Nick re: End of their tether ! (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail Winter (Apr, 11)
HERALD re: End of their tether ! (Apr, 11)
Zbynio Napoleon had the same excuse: Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail winter (Apr, 11)
Robert A. Mosher re: winter (Apr, 11)
Mikhail re: winter (Apr, 11)
 Nick re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 11)
Mikhail re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 12)
BillWilson re: winter (Apr, 14)
 Mikhail re: winter (Apr, 14)
BillWilson re: winter (Apr, 14)
Anatoly re: About Russian winter (Apr, 14)
morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 15)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 15)
 Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 16)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 17)
 morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 17)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 18)
 morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 19)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 20)
 Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 20)
  •  morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 21)
     Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 21)
  • Anatoly re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 17)

    Records: 36

    Threads navigation:  189 <<<  188  >>> 187