Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Mikhail:
re: About Russian winter

Well Morgan, lets be practical. You can't predict anything, especially in war. Germans were only mobile in battle not every where else. When you read of German material losses there is a large number of horses involved.

Germans should have known of the Russian weather?
It's hard to say. Russians also experienced rasputsitsa and winter in the same way, if not worse and won. See for the kind of battles the Germans conducted they felt they had to be fully prepared. At Kursk, if to believe official version, they waited for Tigers and Ferdinands. Not that it really mattered in the Battle of Kursk, from what we know now, but because that might have saved a few lives and put the battle field under their control Germans have waited. Same in the battle of Moscow. They had enough to defend not enough to offend. In Stalingrad of course it was different, there they were surrounded. In the kind of economic system the Germans had it was not very much possible to produce so much needed equipment in the needed period of time, for a full preparation. And since the Germans did not attack with a bare minimum their offensive plans took a long time, just like with citadele. Plus in 1941 German industry was not prepared for war, at all. That's why the Germans ran out of supplies and went on the defensive in the battle of Moscow. However, during the winter and spring of 42 they build up a little more weapons and continued the fight.

Yet the Russians attacked at times when they had minimum to attack with especially in the beginning years of the war.

I agree with you the winter is an excuse. The winter clothing was there, Germans had enough ammunition and winter gear they just didn't take the risk and any war is risk. Russians did, and they won.

Thu Apr 20 01:03:19 2000


Back to page 

 HERALD About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
Henkster Western History = German History (Apr, 11)
Greg Leon Guerrero re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
George Hogg re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Valera Potapov re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
HERALD re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Valera Potapov re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
Trapo re: About Russian winter (Apr, 11)
Nick re: Horses? "General MUD!! (Apr, 11)
Max re: Horses?  (Apr, 11)
Nick re: End of their tether ! (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail Winter (Apr, 11)
HERALD re: End of their tether ! (Apr, 11)
Zbynio Napoleon had the same excuse: Russian winter (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail winter (Apr, 11)
Robert A. Mosher re: winter (Apr, 11)
Mikhail re: winter (Apr, 11)
 Nick re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 11)
Mikhail re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail re: Was either side prepared!?Siberians?? (Apr, 12)
BillWilson re: winter (Apr, 14)
 Mikhail re: winter (Apr, 14)
BillWilson re: winter (Apr, 14)
Anatoly re: About Russian winter (Apr, 14)
morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 15)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 15)
 Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 16)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 17)
 morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 17)
 Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 18)
 morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 19)
  •  Mikhail re: About Russian winter (Apr, 20)
     Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 20)
     morgan samuels re: About Russian winter (Apr, 21)
     Max re: About Russian winter (Apr, 21)
  • Anatoly re: to Morgan Samuels (Apr, 17)

    Records: 36

    Threads navigation:  189 <<<  188  >>> 187