Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Scott Fraser:
re: Hitler's folly

If Stalin had given Kirponos and Budeny a timely withdrawal order, then the whole of Russian Kiev concentration would have been saved (700,000), would have withdrawn and would have probably hit Germans during their drive to Moscow into the flank.

True, many of the men might have escaped captivity, but very much doubt they would have not been able to do so with their heavy equipment. The Germans were much more mobile than the Red Army, and any retreat would have resulted in them discarding these things which slowed them down. They would need to be remustered into new units and re-equipped before they could conduct any further offensive operations, if weapons could be found to re-equip them. It is a big "if". Many of the irregular defenders of Moscow went to the Front without weapons, with instructions to use those captured from the enemy or taken from their dead.

I can give you dozens of such �if�s� and Stalin�s blunders on the Russian side that would have changed the course of the War. Therefore, I believe that blaming Hitler, like, some German historians of the old school tend to do, is looking for Scapegoats, downplaying their own weaknesses and blunders and basically avoiding responsibility. Such approaches were good for the post war period, when no data was available on Soviet dispositions, intentions etc, now they are dated.

I would generaly be inclined to agree with you, however in this instance there is ample documentation in both contemporary personal and official diaries, etc. that I will acccept the judgement that it was Hitler's decision to switch his forces away from the Moscow axis. Both Hitler and Stalin ended up with an assortment of sycophants around their person, however these were front-line commanders, not headquarters toadies, and they took their profession seriously. They were also very good at it.

As for Barbarossa being decisive, in a more general context that is certainly true, but this discussion started out in search of a single battle, which Barbarossa was not. I have already stipulated that the Russian people would likely have rallied and eventually thrown the Germans out, but the loss of Moscow could have delayed that by many years, and may have given the Germans sufficient advantage to go much farther than they did.

Fri Apr 14 19:39:33 2000


Back to page 

Zbynio The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
Sofija re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
Radik re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
 Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
 Nick re: .What the fuck kind of answer is this?!!! (Apr, 10)
Andreas Larka re: .What the fuck kind of answer is this?!!! (Apr, 11)
 Mark E. Horan re: .This language is inappropriate children (Apr, 11)
Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
Zbynio re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 11)
 Max re: to Mikhail (Apr, 11)
David Glantz re: to Mikhail (Apr, 11)
Zbynio I fully agree with David (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail Great Battles (Apr, 11)
 Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
David Glantz re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
ANZAC re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
Scott Fraser re: Battle of Britain (Apr, 12)
Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
 Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
 Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
 Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
Tero Winter War - a strategically important battle ? (Apr, 12)
Zbynio re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
 Samuel vastly out numbered? (Apr, 13)
Scott Fraser re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
 Max re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
Scott Fraser re: vastly out numbered (Apr, 14)
 Max re: vastly out numbered (Apr, 14)
Paul Lakowski re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
 Max re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
 Mikhail re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
Samuel re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 17)
 Amedeo Matteucci Figures for manpower (Apr, 15)
morgan samuels Some quick numbers. (Apr, 15)
 Anatoly re: Paul Lakovski (Apr, 17)
 Zbynio Among my friends, wargamers in USA, the greatest and most ... (Apr, 18)
 James Quinn France 1940 anyone? (Apr, 12)
 Mikhail re: France 1940 anyone? (Apr, 12)
 James Quinn re: France 1940 anyone? (Apr, 12)
 Jeff Gringer Interesting point (Apr, 12)
 Max What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
Jari Lievonen re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
Max re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
Mikhail Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
 Max re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
 Mikhail re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
Scott Fraser re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
morgan samuels re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 15)
Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 12)
 Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 12)
Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
 Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
 Max re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
 Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
Max re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
 Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
  • Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
  •  Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
    Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 15)
    Jari Lievonen Max, see below (Apr, 13)
     Max re: Max, see below (Apr, 13)
    morgan samuels re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 15)
    Mikhail re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
     Max Dear Mikhail, you must be kidding with 10,000,000 ... (Apr, 12)
     T.J.A.Heikkila re: About "important" battles (Apr, 12)
     Mikhail re: Dear Mikhail, you must be kidding with 10,000,000 ... (Apr, 12)
     Heino The Mother of all battles!!!!!!!!!!! (Apr, 13)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 18)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 18)
    Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 18)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)

    Records: 81

    Threads navigation:  188 <<<  187  >>> 186