Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Alex:
re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy

I rate Rokossovsky higher than anybody among "field" top brass. Just read his memoirs... Extremely intelligent and with good sense of humour, unlike many others. In addition, he made little mistakes at the initial period of war. His operational art was undoubtedly higher than Zhukov's, while, yes, Zhukov was most succesful in the "die hard - no way out" situations like Leningrad blockade. Rokossovsky was TOO talented and TOO internally independent to take Zhukov's place. This is not to mention his Polish roots.
As to General Staff, Antonov, not Vasilevsky was the man who actually determined the operation state of art :-) after Shaposhnikov's retirement.

Best
Alex

Fri Apr 14 12:52:17 2000


Back to page 

 Murph Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 11)
 Max re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 11)
David Glantz re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 11)
 Mitch Williamson re: David where would you rate Fyodor Ivanovich Tolbukhin (Apr, 12)
Henkster A Ranking (Apr, 13)
David Glantz re: A Ranking (Apr, 13)
Nick re:Cannot really"RANK" Zhukov (Apr, 13)
Sofija Shaposhnikov - Forgotten Marshal (Apr, 13)
  • Alex re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 14)
     Murph re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 15)
     Kostia re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 19)
  • Records: 11

    Threads navigation:  191 <<<  190  >>> 189