Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

David Glantz:
re: A Ranking

Dear Mitch and others:

This is a difficult question since many commanders had to perform missions they objected to. Tolbukhin's record included defeats like that suffered in the Donbas in February 1943 and at Nikopol' in late 1943 and a string of victories in the Ukraine and Hungary, including the famed defeat of German Sixth SS Panzer Army at Balaton in March 1945. Noth he and Malinovsky require reassessment based on documents.
Cherniakhovsky's record was illustrious but he was Jewish and, depending on the period, his reputation suffered for it. He was most capable. Vatutin was one of the most audacious front commanders, but Stalin did not like him and this effected his record.

Konev was associated with numerous disasters (Smolensk 1941, Viaz'ma 1941, and Mars 1942), but performed brilliantly in 1944 and 1945, particularly during Vistula-Oder and Berlin.

Eremenko flamed out early in his fight with Gudarian, but his later wartime record was mixed.

All of this argues for better access to these officers' extensive personnel records and a concerted effort to write new biographies based on these records and the many rediscovered operations.

David Glantz

Thu Apr 13 15:53:30 2000


Back to page 

 Murph Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 11)
 Max re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 11)
David Glantz re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 11)
 Mitch Williamson re: David where would you rate Fyodor Ivanovich Tolbukhin (Apr, 12)
Henkster A Ranking (Apr, 13)
  • David Glantz re: A Ranking (Apr, 13)
    Nick re:Cannot really"RANK" Zhukov (Apr, 13)
    Sofija Shaposhnikov - Forgotten Marshal (Apr, 13)
  • Alex re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 14)
     Murph re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 15)
     Kostia re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 19)

    Records: 11

    Threads navigation:  191 <<<  190  >>> 189