Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Scott Fraser:
re: Hitler's folly

I would suggest that the Battle of Moscow sealed the Wehrmacht's fate. The Germans could have taken Moscow without difficulty in August 1941, before the Soviets had reinforced the city or been able to recall the forces from the Far East. Moscow is critical to the road, rail and river transportation nets in Russia, sitting at the center of all three. Had the Germans severed these communications by occupying the city, it would have made the movement of goods and personnel extremely difficult for the Soviets, and greatly hampered their ability to supply and reinforce the Red Army. The impact on morale would have been significant for both sides, and it may have been decisive in a possible German victory.

However, on 19 July, after the Battle of Smolensk, Hitler ordered Heersgruppe Mitte to advance on Moscow without armour, dispatching Guderian's 2.Panzergruppe to join Kleist's 1.Panzergruppe in the Ukraine, sending Hoth's 3.Panzergruppe to invest Leningrad, and withdrawing Hoepner's 4.Panzergruppe to Germany. A week later he changed his mind and ordered Von Bock to assume a defensive posture with Heersgruppe Mitte. His generals were unanimous in opposing this strategy, but their objections fell of deaf ears. Finally on 5 September, Hitler reversed himself and ordered VIII Fliegerkorps, 3.Panzergruppe and part of 4.Panzergruppe to move from the Leningrad area back towards moscow, and called 2.Panzergruppe and Weich's 2.Armee to advance from the Ukraine to face the South-West Front. Guderian had unfinished business in the Ukrain, namely the investment of huge pockets of the red Army around Kiev, and did not return to face the forces defending Moscow for another three weeks. Army Group Center sat idle on the raod to Moscow from the beginning of August until the first week of October, and the loss of this good campaigning weather proved decisive. By the time the Werhmacht was ready to resume the advance on the Soviet capital, the weather was turning, and their chance ...

>>> 

Wed Apr 12 21:28:34 2000


Back to page 

Zbynio The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
Sofija re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
Radik re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
 Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
 Nick re: .What the fuck kind of answer is this?!!! (Apr, 10)
Andreas Larka re: .What the fuck kind of answer is this?!!! (Apr, 11)
 Mark E. Horan re: .This language is inappropriate children (Apr, 11)
Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
Zbynio re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 11)
 Max re: to Mikhail (Apr, 11)
David Glantz re: to Mikhail (Apr, 11)
Zbynio I fully agree with David (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail Great Battles (Apr, 11)
 Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
David Glantz re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
ANZAC re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
Scott Fraser re: Battle of Britain (Apr, 12)
Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
 Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
 Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
 Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
Tero Winter War - a strategically important battle ? (Apr, 12)
Zbynio re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
 Samuel vastly out numbered? (Apr, 13)
Scott Fraser re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
 Max re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
Scott Fraser re: vastly out numbered (Apr, 14)
 Max re: vastly out numbered (Apr, 14)
Paul Lakowski re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
 Max re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
 Mikhail re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
Samuel re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 17)
 Amedeo Matteucci Figures for manpower (Apr, 15)
morgan samuels Some quick numbers. (Apr, 15)
 Anatoly re: Paul Lakovski (Apr, 17)
 Zbynio Among my friends, wargamers in USA, the greatest and most ... (Apr, 18)
 James Quinn France 1940 anyone? (Apr, 12)
 Mikhail re: France 1940 anyone? (Apr, 12)
 James Quinn re: France 1940 anyone? (Apr, 12)
 Jeff Gringer Interesting point (Apr, 12)
 Max What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
Jari Lievonen re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
Max re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
Mikhail Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
 Max re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
 Mikhail re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
Scott Fraser re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
morgan samuels re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 15)
  • Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 12)
     Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 12)
    Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
     Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
    Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
     Max re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
     Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
    Max re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
     Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
    Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
     Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
    Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 15)
    Jari Lievonen Max, see below (Apr, 13)
     Max re: Max, see below (Apr, 13)
    morgan samuels re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 15)
  • Mikhail re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
     Max Dear Mikhail, you must be kidding with 10,000,000 ... (Apr, 12)
     T.J.A.Heikkila re: About "important" battles (Apr, 12)
     Mikhail re: Dear Mikhail, you must be kidding with 10,000,000 ... (Apr, 12)
     Heino The Mother of all battles!!!!!!!!!!! (Apr, 13)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 18)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 18)
    Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 18)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)

    Records: 81

    Threads navigation:  188 <<<  187  >>> 186