Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Mikhail:
re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone

Well, Max, it wasn't just the 3,000,000. Actually by 1943 Germany was fully mobilized it was actually 10,000,000 Germans under arms, probably the entire male population. Plus, there were allies. Rumania, Hungary, Austria, Bulgaria, Finland, Italy (to some extant), Croatia, many volunteers from France, Spain and Russia itself. At its highest point USSR had what 9,000,000 men under arms and that was I think in 1944? Well the Weichmarcht in 1943-44 had probably over 12-13. We are talking about a great number of man and equipment. Equipment. In 1943 Germany went into complete military economy and was producing many arms, even with ally bombing, on a very large scale. It had probably over 10,000,000 slaved laborers plus entire Europe for production. Natural resources, however, were a little more scarce than in USSR but enough to engage in a war and prolong it for a good deal of time. You are right, soviet union managed to beat Germans in Stalingrad and Moscow without much help from allies, however, these were very costly victories, I don't think that the Soviet Union would have been able to sustain such victories any further. May be if right after Stalingrad the Soviets had more Pullman cars, locomotives, railroad tracks, and canned food the entire army group South would have been destroyed and the war would end much earlier. Who knows?

Plus one more thing you have to remember, allies bombed Germany. They did not slow down the production that much and probably killed more slaved laborers than Germans, and brought sustainable damage. But, they did make Germans redirect their resources to fight yet another enemy. Building submarines, fighters, and coastal defences and holding 30 divisions in the West is a big deal. Plus, Luftwaffe. More airplanes were shot down in the Western theater than any place else in the war. To whatever anybody says Germany could sustain the losses in man and personal, however, these resources were used in the west not the east.

Of course there is another thing. There is no way Soviet army would stop in the middle somewhere in Poland and conclude an armistice with the Germans. Probably not, but yet who knows. Soviet Union did not have as many men as you think they did and could not produce as much as everyone says. It didn't have that many young man to send into battle.

Wed Apr 12 20:14:20 2000


Back to page 

Zbynio The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
Sofija re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
Radik re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
 Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
 Nick re: .What the fuck kind of answer is this?!!! (Apr, 10)
Andreas Larka re: .What the fuck kind of answer is this?!!! (Apr, 11)
 Mark E. Horan re: .This language is inappropriate children (Apr, 11)
Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 10)
Zbynio re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 11)
 Max re: to Mikhail (Apr, 11)
David Glantz re: to Mikhail (Apr, 11)
Zbynio I fully agree with David (Apr, 11)
 Mikhail Great Battles (Apr, 11)
 Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
David Glantz re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
ANZAC re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
Scott Fraser re: Battle of Britain (Apr, 12)
Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
 Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
 Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
Paul Lakowski re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
 Mikhail re: Great Battles (Apr, 13)
Tero Winter War - a strategically important battle ? (Apr, 12)
Zbynio re: Great Battles (Apr, 12)
 Samuel vastly out numbered? (Apr, 13)
Scott Fraser re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
 Max re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
Scott Fraser re: vastly out numbered (Apr, 14)
 Max re: vastly out numbered (Apr, 14)
Paul Lakowski re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
 Max re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
 Mikhail re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 14)
Samuel re: vastly out numbered? (Apr, 17)
 Amedeo Matteucci Figures for manpower (Apr, 15)
morgan samuels Some quick numbers. (Apr, 15)
 Anatoly re: Paul Lakovski (Apr, 17)
 Zbynio Among my friends, wargamers in USA, the greatest and most ... (Apr, 18)
 James Quinn France 1940 anyone? (Apr, 12)
 Mikhail re: France 1940 anyone? (Apr, 12)
 James Quinn re: France 1940 anyone? (Apr, 12)
 Jeff Gringer Interesting point (Apr, 12)
 Max What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
Jari Lievonen re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
Max re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
Mikhail Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
 Max re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
  •  Mikhail re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
    Scott Fraser re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 12)
    morgan samuels re: Russians winning of WW2 in Germany alone (Apr, 15)
  • Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 12)
     Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 12)
    Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
     Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
    Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
     Max re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
     Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
    Max re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
     Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
    Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
     Mikhail re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 14)
    Scott Fraser re: Hitler's folly  (Apr, 15)
    Jari Lievonen Max, see below (Apr, 13)
     Max re: Max, see below (Apr, 13)
    morgan samuels re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 15)
    Mikhail re: What ultimately decided the outcome of WW2 (Apr, 12)
     Max Dear Mikhail, you must be kidding with 10,000,000 ... (Apr, 12)
     T.J.A.Heikkila re: About "important" battles (Apr, 12)
     Mikhail re: Dear Mikhail, you must be kidding with 10,000,000 ... (Apr, 12)
     Heino The Mother of all battles!!!!!!!!!!! (Apr, 13)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 18)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 18)
    Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 18)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
    Trapo re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Max re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)
     Mikhail re: The Greatest Battle of WW 2 (Apr, 19)

    Records: 81

    Threads navigation:  188 <<<  187  >>> 186