Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Murph:
Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy

When comparing wartime Red Army commanders, Zhukov usually gets a great deal of praise. However from my readings from Glantz, Carell, etc I have come to the conclusion that Konev, and Rokossovskyy were actually better commanders since they used maneuver rather than the sledge-hammer tactics that were so wasteful of manpower tha Zhukov favored. Do the members of the forum have a different opinion?

Tue Apr 11 15:54:24 2000


Back to page 

  •  Murph Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 11)
     Max re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 11)
    David Glantz re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 11)
     Mitch Williamson re: David where would you rate Fyodor Ivanovich Tolbukhin (Apr, 12)
    Henkster A Ranking (Apr, 13)
    David Glantz re: A Ranking (Apr, 13)
    Nick re:Cannot really"RANK" Zhukov (Apr, 13)
    Sofija Shaposhnikov - Forgotten Marshal (Apr, 13)
    Alex re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 14)
     Murph re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 15)
     Kostia re: Zhukov vs Konev vs Rokossovskyy (Apr, 19)
  • Records: 11

    Threads navigation:  191 <<<  190  >>> 189