Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 R. Veenenberg:
re: What happened at Brody 1944?

Ok, Stehan, thanks a lot. Some of my fears are removed by your research/analysis. I did found something about the 506th hvy bn. which was at the time at Brody (outside the pocket).
If your anaylis maybe true, then Brody was not such a terrible dissaster compared to the Minsk, Vitebsk, Korsun and Husi/Kishinev pockets.
In my asking about Cherkassy/Korsun some Soviet guys in the Forum believe that the German saving of troops is pure propaganda.
Do you have reasons to doubt German claims?
In my opinion Germans never lie on statistical subjects. They are too sophisticated and too scientific to lie about numbers.
By the way: now I want you to comment on the dreadfull numbers (Soviet claims) of those German guys which were trapped at Kishinev and were so quickly routed that there was no time to die or starve from lack of food. Can it be true that 100.000 Germans were killed there (with insignificant Soviet losses) or was this a butchers paradise with equal losses on the Soviet side and substantial Soviet killings of thens-of-thousands Germans straight after that battle. Now Brody is over this big question still remains unsolved.

Stehan, please do give it a try!!!

Rob

Sat Apr 8 21:36:47 2000


Back to page 

R. Veenenberg What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
David Glantz re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 30)
 Paul Lakowski re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Trapo re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Max re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Mikhail re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Paul Lakowski re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 30)
Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 30)
 R. Veenenberg re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 31)
 Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Apr, 4)
  •  R. Veenenberg re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Apr, 8)
    Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Apr, 11)
     Fred What happened at Brody (Apr, 13)
  •  Mikhail To Paul (Mar, 30)
    David Glantz re: To Paul (Mar, 31)
     Maxim re: To Mikhail (Mar, 31)
     Mikhail To Mr. Glantz (Mar, 31)
    David Glantz re: To Mr. Glantz (Apr, 1)
     Greg Leon Guerrero re: To Mr. Glantz (Apr, 1)
     Jeff Gringer To Mr. Guerrero (Apr, 7)
     Paul Lakowski re: To Paul (Apr, 2)

    Records: 22

    Threads navigation:  158 <<<  157  >>> 156