Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Stephen:
re: What happened at Brody 1944?

Hi Rob,

I�m sorry for taking so long to respond. The account about the 10 Tigers came from Captain P. Sylenko. Captain D. Ferkuniak mentions being supported by 1 Tiger. Both these men were with the Galicia Division and were in the area around Kniaze, preparing for a breakout attempt. The dates were from July 21 to 23. Because of the area, date and the number of tanks, it would seem that a company of Tigers from the 506 were the ones left in the pocket or they inadvertently wondered into it. I have thumbed through several books on Tigers but nothing is said about 506 during this time period. I haven�t had a chance to see Schneider�s book �Tigers in Combat�, so I don�t know if he mentions this time period.

The number 10,000 seems to low from my perspective, but it could be on how the authors defined the XIII Corps. Some Authors do not include the 340th ID, but include the 349th even though it only became subordinate when it was cut off from the 48th Pz Corps. Another reason is the Galicia Division alone had 3000 men accounted for right after the battle and the count went to 5300 men by September (some of the men had been used by other Divisions during the rest of the Soviet offensive and couldn�t return). The number I used 24,758 was taken from the document and probably uses men that were not even there or just convalescing, but still part of the Divisions. But even with this, I think the number would still be 20,000+ that came out of the battle before and after the XIII Corps was in the pocket for the following reason. If you remove 20% of the rough total of 47,000 (the approx. total of KAC, 361st, 349th, 340, 454th in the document) for troops away from the Divisions (as mentioned above), you still have around 37,600. . Also with 20% out of each Division, it tends to meet the estimated 7,000 to 9,000 per Division that is mentioned in most books. The only one that doesn�t meet this is obviously the 454th SD, which had about 4,700 men. MIA and KIA were listed as 21,495, which leave about 16,000 survivors from the above. If you include the Galicia Division (5300) and independent units, this exceeds 20,000.
On the Divisional strengths that totaled about 47,000, I don�t think the Germans just picked those numbers arbitrarily. I think they must have had some type of documentation to substantiate their record keeping at that time.
Please understand these are just numbers and my thoughts.

Best wishes,

Stephen

Tue Apr 4 09:18:50 2000


Back to page 

R. Veenenberg What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
David Glantz re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 30)
 Paul Lakowski re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Trapo re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Max re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Mikhail re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Paul Lakowski re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 30)
Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 30)
 R. Veenenberg re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 31)
  •  Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Apr, 4)
     R. Veenenberg re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Apr, 8)
    Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Apr, 11)
     Fred What happened at Brody (Apr, 13)
  •  Mikhail To Paul (Mar, 30)
    David Glantz re: To Paul (Mar, 31)
     Maxim re: To Mikhail (Mar, 31)
     Mikhail To Mr. Glantz (Mar, 31)
    David Glantz re: To Mr. Glantz (Apr, 1)
     Greg Leon Guerrero re: To Mr. Glantz (Apr, 1)
     Jeff Gringer To Mr. Guerrero (Apr, 7)
     Paul Lakowski re: To Paul (Apr, 2)

    Records: 22

    Threads navigation:  158 <<<  157  >>> 156