Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Jari Lievonen:
On the book

Hi,

I don't quite agree with your comment on the book being totally useless as history. One just has to reflect it against other sources. However, if the sources used prove out to be fabricated or misquoted then it is naturally an other matter.

I don't think that the writer made any claims on objectivity. If I remeber correctly he based his information on German intelligence information collected from Russian radio and telephone traffic. The material was later captured by americans. As such the book gives an idea what Germans new (or thought they knew) at the time of the attack. It also gives reflection on what German thought of their own success at the time and how the picture has since changed -given that you don't rely on this book alone.

What comes to Red Army being just "a nuissance" in the beginning of the war the author is not far off the mark. Many Red Army soldiers fought hard from the onset but the confusion in Russian command structure is pretty clear regardless of the source one uses. This book underlines the fact more than most. Stavka had simply underestimated the speed that Germans could keep up. And the millions of POW's at the beginning of the war were also a clear sign of utter confusion on all levels. But in the end the Red Army rallied and attributing that only to Hitler's mistakes is far from accurate. In this respect the author has definitely found his "culprint".

The "what if" part is far less usefull as stated before.

Jari

Mon Apr 3 13:40:52 2000


Back to page 

Samuel Hitler's Panzers East : World War II Reinterpreted  (Apr, 3)
Jari Lievonen re: Hitler's Panzers East : World War II Reinterpreted  (Apr, 3)
 Max re: Hitler's Panzers East : World War II Reinterpreted  (Apr, 3)
  • Jari Lievonen On the book  (Apr, 3)
  • Records: 4

    Threads navigation:  171 <<<  170  >>> 169