| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
Dear Mikhail,
I am sorry that your family has seen so much horror. No one should have to go through that.
I am American, and of split culture: my father is from an island in the Western Pacific, Guam, my Mom, from the State of Pennsylvania. During WWII, Guam was occupied by, first, the Japanese Navy, and then the Japanese Army. I remember once, while still a child, asking my grandmother if the Japanese were really bad then. All she said was, "The Navy was better." Many years later, in a discussion with my father, I brought this up. He told me that my grandmother had hated the Japanese for what they did on Guam during the war, but was so nice a person that this was all she could say without being mean. I too lost family during the occupation of Guam, though nothing like in your terrible circumstances. War is pure horror.
I am also sorry that you feel Mr. Glantz appears biased towards the Germans. As an American I have found it to be the opposite. I still remember reading the concluding chapter to "Clash of Titans" when Mr. Glantz wrote that if anyone deserved to be considered the person most responsible for winning the war in Europe, it should not be Eisenhower, but Zhukov, Vasilevky, or even Stalin. That passage went on to compare the scale of the war in Russia with western Allied efforts, from N. Africa to Normandy. After reading that, one comes away with a sense of the immensity of the Great Patriotic War. Also, every book I have read by Mr. Glantz shows the conflict from primarily the Soviet side. Of course, the German side needs to be shown as well for the sake of balance, and understanding, but his books are about the Red Army, not the Wehrmacht. My impression of Mr. Glantz from his works is that here is a person who has committed himself to showing the Soviet side of WWII. And, that this deep conviction is due to a belief that the Soviet Union was the deciding factor in the defeat of Germany.
As an American, I know just how much Mr. Glantz's work goes against the grain of popular perception in the United States. And, not only from the more casually informed either. Many very educated people here refuse to see the obvious, because of political, national, or other biased reasons.
Sat Apr 1 13:51:01 2000