Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Valera Potapov:
re: Suvorov's credibility?

"you consider the facts mentioned by Suvorov"

Kostya, I would be very glad to see at least ONE fact mentioned by Suvorov, unfortunaterly I was unable to find them in his three volumes.

"OK, so you can't post anything from books of Glantz, Gorodetski, Volkogonov, actually you can't post anything from any book, because these are not good sources! Logical thinking?"

A book is not a SOURCE. This is just a book. It can be good book, it can be bad. Anyway this is not a source. A SOURCE is a DOCUMENT that is signed by responsible person(s). A book is not a source, it's an authour's thoughts and points. A book is usually based on different sources which can contain contradictory infarmation and aouthr's job it to try to inderstand and to choose the most probable (acceptable) version.

"I agree, you didn't say anything about Stalin preparing for defence, but you've said that Stalin planned to attack in 42, and I feel that this text somewhat proves that he wanted to attack a bit earlier."

I don't know what he wanted in fact, I just think in 1941 the Red Army was absolutely unprepared for any serious offensive operations.

I don't know what Stalin wanted, however by June 22, 1941, there were no any reasonable offensive plans. I'm very doubt such a plan was impossible to create for two weeks. Creation of such a complex document would take quite long time.

I think, if an offensive order would be given however, the results would be much worse as it happened in fact after launching the Barbarossa.

Fri Mar 31 17:25:11 2000


Back to page 

AndyW Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
 AndyW re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 31)
  •  Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 31)
     Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Apr, 1)
     Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Apr, 1)
  •  Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
     Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
     Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
    Scott Fraser re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
    David Glantz re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
     Tero Maybe out of context, but... (Mar, 26)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
    David Glantz re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
    Scott Fraser re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
    Tero Territorial aspirations (Mar, 26)
    Scott Fraser re: Territorial aspirations (Mar, 29)
     Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
    Tero Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
    Tero re: Soviet failure (Mar, 28)
    Kostia re: Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
    Tero Please ellaborate (Mar, 28)
    Kostia re: Please ellaborate (Mar, 28)
    Tero re: Please ellaborate (Mar, 29)
    Scott Fraser re: Soviet failure (Mar, 29)
    Tero A Pyrhian victory ? (Mar, 29)
     Sami re: A Pyrhian victory ? (Mar, 29)
    Tero A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
     Sami re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
    Tero re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
     Sami re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
     Kostia re: Soviet failure (Mar, 29)
    Tero Losses and boozing (Mar, 30)
     Heino re: Losses and boozing (Mar, 30)
    Tero No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
     Heino re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
    Heino re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Kostia re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Kostia How come? (Mar, 31)
    Tero re: How come? (Mar, 31)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Sami re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Mikhail re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
    Sami ....counting the bodies.... (Mar, 31)
     Tero Joint Russo-Finnish research (Mar, 31)
    Jari Lievonen Winter War losses (Mar, 31)
     Heino re: To Tero (Mar, 31)
     Mikhail re: To Tero (Mar, 31)
    Robert A. Mosher re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
    Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
     Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Jorge Visca re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
    Scott Fraser re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
    Albert re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
    Mikhail re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
     Kostia re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)

    Records: 83

    Threads navigation:  142 <<<  141  >>> 140