Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Tero:
re: No fiction, just facts

>I accept most of your arguments. I understand Finns were fighting a just war from their perspective and so were capable of miracles.

Please name an other nation that went against Stalin in arms and emerged more or less intact (by intact I mean with the same leaders, the same form of government it had before the conflict and most of its territory undivided and/or not occupied by Soviet forces). If that constitutes a miracle so be it.

>Here are my arguments. First of all, comparison with Verdum is unfair. The scale was much smaller and the fighting took place in wooded terrain, whereas Flanders, as you know, is just plains and you�re right all you have to do is just aim and mow�em down.

The comparison is not unfair. That is how the battles were fought in the Isthmus. The terrain was wooded, yes. But the terrain in the western part of the Isthmus is the best tank country in the region. That means less forest (not much but still) and more fields. The defensive line followed the edge of the forest and rivers so the attacker had to come over frozen rivers or snow covered fields. The style the Red Army used was WWI style human wave assault with heavy artillery preparations. And yes, they had to just aim and mow them down.

The wooded terrain was predominant only in northern battles.

If you can obtain the Finnish movie Winter War you can get a look at what it was all like in the Isthmus. It is an excellent movie and it is historically accurate, down to the small arms and T-26 tanks and all. The terrain used in the film was almost 100% match to the terrain the actual battles.

>Second, Brits were stockpiling shells for months in a row before the offensive. The whole of England produced nothing but shells for that famous artillery offensive barrage. Excuse me but Finnish capacities at the time were much smaller.

Whereas the Soviet capabilities exceeded that of England by that time. And it was the Soviets who attacked, not the Finns. The Soviets made preparations ...

>>> 

Fri Mar 31 16:05:46 2000


Back to page 

AndyW Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
 AndyW re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 31)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 31)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Apr, 1)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Apr, 1)
 Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
Scott Fraser re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
David Glantz re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
 Tero Maybe out of context, but... (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
David Glantz re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Scott Fraser re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Tero Territorial aspirations (Mar, 26)
Scott Fraser re: Territorial aspirations (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Tero Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Albert re: Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Tero re: Soviet failure (Mar, 28)
Kostia re: Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Tero Please ellaborate (Mar, 28)
Kostia re: Please ellaborate (Mar, 28)
Tero re: Please ellaborate (Mar, 29)
Scott Fraser re: Soviet failure (Mar, 29)
Tero A Pyrhian victory ? (Mar, 29)
 Sami re: A Pyrhian victory ? (Mar, 29)
Tero A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
 Sami re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
Tero re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
 Sami re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
 Kostia re: Soviet failure (Mar, 29)
Tero Losses and boozing (Mar, 30)
 Heino re: Losses and boozing (Mar, 30)
Tero No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
 Heino re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
Heino re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
 Kostia re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
 Kostia How come? (Mar, 31)
Tero re: How come? (Mar, 31)
  • Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Sami re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
  •  Mikhail re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
    Sami ....counting the bodies.... (Mar, 31)
     Tero Joint Russo-Finnish research (Mar, 31)
    Jari Lievonen Winter War losses (Mar, 31)
     Heino re: To Tero (Mar, 31)
     Mikhail re: To Tero (Mar, 31)
    Robert A. Mosher re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
    Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
     Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Jorge Visca re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
    Scott Fraser re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
    Albert re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
    Mikhail re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
     Kostia re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)

    Records: 83

    Threads navigation:  142 <<<  141  >>> 140