Jari Lievonen:
re: Where is the beef?
Hi Mikhail,
I'll try to be more specific. All the information below is from Finnish Aces of World War 2 by Kari Stenman and Kalevi Keskinen.
Soviet airforce had some 1.300 planes (13th air army) and 220 navy planes allocated to the attack in the Isthmus June 9th, 1944.
Against this force Finns could originally send 14 Bf 109 G's (HLeLv24), 16 Bf 109 G6's (HLeLv 34) and 18 Brewsters (HLeLv 26). The two squadrons equipt with Me 109's received additional planes in June 19, which increased their strength close to 25 planes each (so about 50 me 109 G's).
German detachment Kuhlmey that was sent to help by Luftwaffe had some 25 Stuka's and 15 FW 190 fighters plus some Me 109 reconnaissance planes.
Finnish fighter pilots claimed alltogether 425 planes shot down againt the loss of 18 Me 109 planes (10 shot down, 3 missing, 3 by flak and 2 on the ground). Some Brewsters were also lost but I don't have the exact number at hand. From memory I would put the figure at 4. Luftwaffe claimed 126 victories (against 10? of their own losses). So all in all 551 shot down Russian planes claimed against some 30+ planes lost.
13th Air Army reported having just 800 planes left in July 15. Navy plane losses are not reported.
Now, this means that Russian losses were at least 1.300- 800 = 500 (remember Navy losses not known) planes to various reasons. As there must have been accidents, flak and other losses there is some "air" in the claims. Still given that the Russian loss figure is accurate it comes surprisingly close to the claims. But is it correct?
All in all Finnish airforce claimed 1.807 downded Russian aircraft against 257 planes lost in operations during the wars (1939-1940, 1941-1944). Additional 315 own planes were lost in training accidents, transfer fligths etc. Finnish flak claimed have shot down 1.506 planes, but these figures are most likely much more unreliable than air victory claims.
According to the Fighter Aces book "recent research in Russian files has revealed that 1855 Russian aircraft were downed by Finnish fighters". Anyone know about this research in Russia?
Regards,
Jari
Fri Mar 31 13:20:07 2000
Back to page
R. Veenenberg
Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
Max
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
Scott Fraser
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
R. Veenenberg
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
Daniel Olsson
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
Mark E. Horan
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
R. Veenenberg
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 21)
Scott Fraser
re: Defeated, not retreated! (Mar, 22)
Scott Fraser
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
Juha Vaittinen
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 28)
Valera Potapov
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
Max
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
Valera Potapov
Please clarify... (Mar, 19)
...Patrick H
re: Please clarify... (Mar, 20)
Valera Potapov
re: Please clarify... (Mar, 20)
Valera Potapov
BTW... (Mar, 20)
Bob Mackenzie
Rata (Mar, 20)
Scott Fraser
Rata = ����� (Mar, 20)
Alexei Luks
Why Rata? Because (+) (Mar, 20)
Jorge Visca
and... (Mar, 21)
Samuel
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
Max
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
Samuel
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
Albert
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
Sergey V. Majorov
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 21)
Sergey V. Majorov
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 21)
R. Veenenberg
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 21)
PPSh
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 22)
Alex Wood
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 24)
Mikhail
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 24)
Alexei
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 25)
Alex Wood
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 25)
Scott Fraser
re: T-34s on the runway (Mar, 26)
R. Veenenberg
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 29)
Mikhail
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 29)
Juha Vaittinen
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Apr, 3)
PPSh
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Apr, 3)
...
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Apr, 7)
Buddy
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Apr, 7)
PPSh
re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Apr, 11)
Jari Lievonen
Where is the beef? (Mar, 30)
Mikhail
re: Where is the beef? (Mar, 30)
- Jari Lievonen
re: Where is the beef? (Mar, 31)
Records: 43
Threads navigation: 131 <<< 130 >>> 129