Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Maxim:
re: To Mikhail

I don�t think you�re right Mikhail. I�m Russian myself and have read nearly all of the David�s books. His passion for our military history and his resourcefulness are astonishing and worthy of utmost admiration. For various reasons, mostly political, research of this depth was impossible in our country and unfortunately no researchers of this magnitude have emerged in Russia. It�s only natural that people from both sides of the conflict want to hear only flattering things about their country's military performance. This is what we heard for all those years after the war. The idols, such as Zhukov, were and, I think still are for some people, untouchable. The truth, however, is quite different. I believe that what David Glantz is doing, he is trying, while based solely on archival materials of both sides and without any preferences and biases, to establish the truth, which by definition can never be completely pleasant to any of the sides. And he should only be praised for that.

Cheers

Fri Mar 31 13:19:56 2000


Back to page 

R. Veenenberg What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
David Glantz re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 30)
 Paul Lakowski re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Trapo re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Max re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Mikhail re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 29)
Paul Lakowski re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 30)
Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 30)
 R. Veenenberg re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Mar, 31)
 Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Apr, 4)
 R. Veenenberg re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Apr, 8)
Stephen re: What happened at Brody 1944? (Apr, 11)
 Fred What happened at Brody (Apr, 13)
 Mikhail To Paul (Mar, 30)
David Glantz re: To Paul (Mar, 31)
  •  Maxim re: To Mikhail (Mar, 31)
     Mikhail To Mr. Glantz (Mar, 31)
    David Glantz re: To Mr. Glantz (Apr, 1)
     Greg Leon Guerrero re: To Mr. Glantz (Apr, 1)
     Jeff Gringer To Mr. Guerrero (Apr, 7)
     Paul Lakowski re: To Paul (Apr, 2)
  • Records: 22

    Threads navigation:  158 <<<  157  >>> 156