Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Tero:
re: No fiction, just facts

>As far as I know Soviets had overwhelming air superiority. Finns were outgunned, outnumbered and �outtanked�.

Most definitively. But when you say we were outnumbered you have to remember that our army was 340 000 strong at the end of hostilities. Given the axiom an assault will be successfull only if the attacker has 3 or more times as many men that means there must have been at least 1 million ablebodied men + enough reserves to overcome that army. But having the most does not automatically mean it is the best and it does most definitively does not guarantee victory by default. Stalin and the defence counsil forgot that.

>Even allowing for Soviet blunders and clumsiness, Finnish maneuverability, their knowledge of terrain etc., I greatly doubt Finns were capable of inflicting such losses on Soviets.

Why ? The attackers came in upright and massed up. All you had to do was to point your gun and shoot at the mass.

I take it you have no qualms about accepting the casualty figures for Flanders, Somme and the other slaughtergrounds of WWI. Those are pretty much the kind of battle that was fought in the Isthmus and Kollaa (except the Finnish artillery was so ammunition starved it could only help in a REAL emergency. Most attacks could have been stopped with artillery barrages even before they started. That lesson sunk in deep.). The more "glorious" encircements were conducted far north of lake Ladoga. But it was invariably battalions or regiments against often multiple divisions.

In the Isthmus: the Finnish army was mostly on defence (only one major counter attack which failed). The Finnish doctrine dictated that the positions are in posession of friendlies at the of the battle so that meant constant smaller counter attacks to retake positions that had been taken by the Red Army.

The Red Army was attacking a well entrenched, well prepared army determined to defend each inch of the ground. Also, Stalin (and the defence counsil) made a grave error when ...

>>> 

Fri Mar 31 12:09:35 2000


Back to page 

AndyW Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
 AndyW re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 31)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 31)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Apr, 1)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Apr, 1)
 Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
Scott Fraser re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
David Glantz re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
 Tero Maybe out of context, but... (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
David Glantz re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Scott Fraser re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Tero Territorial aspirations (Mar, 26)
Scott Fraser re: Territorial aspirations (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Tero Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Albert re: Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Tero re: Soviet failure (Mar, 28)
Kostia re: Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Tero Please ellaborate (Mar, 28)
Kostia re: Please ellaborate (Mar, 28)
Tero re: Please ellaborate (Mar, 29)
Scott Fraser re: Soviet failure (Mar, 29)
Tero A Pyrhian victory ? (Mar, 29)
 Sami re: A Pyrhian victory ? (Mar, 29)
Tero A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
 Sami re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
Tero re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
 Sami re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
 Kostia re: Soviet failure (Mar, 29)
Tero Losses and boozing (Mar, 30)
 Heino re: Losses and boozing (Mar, 30)
Tero No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
 Heino re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
  • Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
    Heino re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Kostia re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Kostia How come? (Mar, 31)
    Tero re: How come? (Mar, 31)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Sami re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
  •  Mikhail re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
    Sami ....counting the bodies.... (Mar, 31)
     Tero Joint Russo-Finnish research (Mar, 31)
    Jari Lievonen Winter War losses (Mar, 31)
     Heino re: To Tero (Mar, 31)
     Mikhail re: To Tero (Mar, 31)
    Robert A. Mosher re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
    Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
     Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Jorge Visca re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
    Scott Fraser re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
    Albert re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
    Mikhail re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
     Kostia re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)

    Records: 83

    Threads navigation:  142 <<<  141  >>> 140