Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Jari Lievonen:
Where is the beef?

Hello,

After reading all the messages sent into this thread I don't see any hard facts. Russians claim that they shot down 500 German planes in Kursk against loosing 122 of their own. Ok, for arguments sake let us assume that the Russians can count their own losses accurately. How many planes Germans admitted loosing in Kursk? There must be a record of this in some book. There is then good basis for argumentation. The same should apply for Kuban. "I believe" - "I don't believe" has already been checked and it lead nowhere.

Regards,

Jari

PS. In the summer of 1944 Russian army supported it's attack against Finland in the Karelian Isthmus with 1.300 planes. In addition 200 Navy planes participated. In one month of fighting from June 10 to July 15 this force of 1.500 planes was reduced to 800 operational aircraft (this information is supposed to come from Russian archives). During the same period Finns lost 8 Me 109 fighters and Germans 4 Fw 190 in aerial combat over the Isthmus (about 30 more planes were lost in the ground in bombing raids). Finnish claims were some 450 + shot down Russian planes and German claims some 100+. This would leave 150 planes lost to AA, accidents etc. All seems nice and fine but it all depends on information coming from "Russian sources" being accurate. Anyone of our Russian readers have seen anything on the subject?


Thu Mar 30 15:28:55 2000


Back to page 

 R. Veenenberg Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
Max re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
Scott Fraser re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
 R. Veenenberg re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
 Daniel Olsson re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
 Mark E. Horan re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
 R. Veenenberg re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 21)
Scott Fraser re: Defeated, not retreated! (Mar, 22)
Scott Fraser re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
Juha Vaittinen re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 28)
 Valera Potapov re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
Max re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 19)
Valera Potapov Please clarify... (Mar, 19)
...Patrick H re: Please clarify... (Mar, 20)
 Valera Potapov re: Please clarify... (Mar, 20)
 Valera Potapov BTW... (Mar, 20)
Bob Mackenzie Rata (Mar, 20)
Scott Fraser Rata = ����� (Mar, 20)
 Alexei Luks Why Rata? Because (+) (Mar, 20)
 Jorge Visca and... (Mar, 21)
 Samuel re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
Max re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
Samuel re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
Albert re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 20)
Sergey V. Majorov re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 21)
 Sergey V. Majorov re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 21)
R. Veenenberg re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 21)
PPSh re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 22)
 Alex Wood re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 24)
Mikhail re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 24)
Alexei re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 25)
 Alex Wood re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 25)
Scott Fraser re: T-34s on the runway (Mar, 26)
 R. Veenenberg re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 29)
 Mikhail re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Mar, 29)
 Juha Vaittinen re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Apr, 3)
PPSh re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Apr, 3)
 ... re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Apr, 7)
 Buddy re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Apr, 7)
PPSh re: Stunning Soviet Air victories in May 1943??????? (Apr, 11)
  • Jari Lievonen Where is the beef? (Mar, 30)
    Mikhail re: Where is the beef? (Mar, 30)
    Jari Lievonen re: Where is the beef? (Mar, 31)
  • Records: 43

    Threads navigation:  131 <<<  130  >>> 129