| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
Having dug at this subject for the last year, there doesn�t seem to be one source that would cover it all. The major books on WWII in the east, kind of just blow by this battle. Here are some books I would recommend for a start, some of which are mentioned above.
Red Army Tank Commanders, by R.N. Armstrong
L�vov � Sandomierz 1944, Translated by D.M. Glantz and H.S. Orenstein
Bagration 1944, by S. Zaloga (this only has about 8 pages on the subject, but is good for comparing numbers)
From the other side, there has been 4 books written about the Galicia Division in English so far that I am aware of and have read. These books all cover this Divisions part in the battle. Two you might want to look at are.
The Ukrainian Division Galicia, by W.D. Heike
The Galicia Division, by M.O. Logusz
Ostfront 1944, by A. Buchner. He uses information from W. Haupt, who wrote a divisional history on the 8th Panzer Division and from W. Lange who wrote a book about commanding Korpsabteilung C.
There are many other books that might touch on the subject, some are nothing more than divisional histories. For instance, I have been trying to find out if Dmitriy Loza�s book mentions this battle (not sure if he was there), because in the Landwehr book on the Galicia Division, there is a picture of a trooper looking at a knocked out Sherman.
I would say that all the books mentioned have their detractors, depending on which side is favored. So, it�s all really perspective.
For the numbers, according to one document that I have dated March 1, 1945 (the Germans were still trying to account for all the troops of the XIII Corps, to include the 349th ID, but not the Galicia Div.), out of 47,877 troops, 24,758 Heer troops lived and were accounted for after the Battle. This figure can be somewhat misleading depending on the how the overall count was originally figured. I don�t know if the above figures include support units that were attached at this time to the individual divisions, or if units that were cut off are included in it also (there were 10 Tigers and some StugIIIs in the pocket that are almost never mentioned). Some books go as low as 25,000 troops (without the Galicia Division) for the XIII Corps. Because actual troop strengths varies from book to book, and as to not start an argument I would suggest you read the following article in the �Journal of Slavic Military Studies� by Zetterling and Frankson called �Analyzing World War II Eastern Front Battles. There is a section on troop strength. For Soviet casulties, I'm sure some one this site might know the correct numbers.
One of the unfortunate things I have come across about this subject, is that there is next to nothing written about the battle for the city of Brody itself.
Stephen
Thu Mar 30 07:24:26 2000