Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Scott Fraser:
re: Answer to Fred

A nice lecture, but a little bit biased, Scott.
No apology. I will concede to bias, perhaps, but a deliberate bias to emphasize the point that Stalin was hated by as many people who loved him. Certainly the USSR would have fared very differently during the war without the brutal hand of Stalin. It can be said that his forced collectivizations and pursuit of the Five Year Plans without regard for the suffering it caused prepared the country for war, made it stronger and modern enough to be able to rally and resist the Fascist invasion. He remains an enigma to many, including myself, but that does not detract from the reality of his brutality.

He was feared by all, but loved only by the Russians. Those whose rodnoj jazyk was not Russian hated him, because he murdered their relatives, and sent the survivors off to Siberia.

That�s an asinine assertion because no people suffered more from Stalin�s rule than the Russians. If you go to Georgia now, Scott, they still adore their great Georgian. Their president Shevardnadze has recently even laid down some wreaths to Stalin�s monument, the only one still standing by the way.
Are you talking numbers or percentages? The Russians suffered, certainly, but nowhere near the scale of the Ukrainians, Chechens, Kalmyks, Azeriis, etc. These were distinct nationalities who had their unique culture suppressed in programs of "Russification", who lost their right to use their language, who lost their homes and in some cases their homelands, sent packing on a train to Siberia or lowered into a grave. Many more Ukrainians died as a result of Stalin's whims than Russians. A much greated percentage of Chechens suffered at his hands than Russians. Sure, Russians suffered too, but they only bled a little bit compared to other national groups. Even the Georgians were subject to repression, although perhaps they were treated more lightly in comparison to others. In the 1980s I had a friend who was Georgian, ...

>>> 

Thu Mar 30 02:03:33 2000


Back to page 

Albert Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
Scott Fraser re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
Mike Jasinski re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)
Albert re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)
 Valera Potapov re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)
 Nick re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 27)
Kostia re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 27)
 Valera Potapov re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 28)
Kostia re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 28)
 Greg Leon Guerrero re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 31)
 Kostia re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 31)
Jeff Some more thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 28)
Scott Fraser re: Readings (Mar, 29)
Mikhail Question to Scott (Mar, 27)
Scott Fraser re: Answer (Mar, 29)
 Mikhail re: Answer (Mar, 29)
Scott Fraser re: Answer (Mar, 29)
Fred re: Answer (Mar, 29)
  • Scott Fraser re: Answer to Fred (Mar, 30)
    Fred re: Answer to Scott (Mar, 30)
  • Mikhail re: Answer to Scott (Mar, 30)
    Kostia re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)

    Records: 24

    Threads navigation:  148 <<<  147  >>> 146