Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Sami:
re: A Pyrhian victory ?

I agree with Tero's post, except with one thing...it would've taken a lot longer to get all the way to Helsinki. The Finns would've retreated to the Kymi-river, and the frontline would've shortened a lot. And as the spring thaws were closing, that would've made the Soviet supply even more difficult (not to mention attacks), the Soviet advance wouldn't have been radically faster.
I'm not saying, that the Finnish government made a mistake when they sued for peace (quite the opposite), but I don't agree that Helsinki would've fallen in a few weeks.

As for the SU's situation in the last days of the war, to get into war with the western allies on the "German" side (thus helping Germany, SU's most probable enemy in the future) was something Stalin didn't want.

The political cost of the war (for the SU) was quite high. To the world, the attack against Finland was seen as an unjustified attack against a small neutral democratic state, which couldn't endanger Leningrad.
The creation of the puppet government of Finland (the peoples government of O.W.Kuusinen) was another big mistake by Stalin, which furthermore made the Soviet case more unjustified in the eyes of the world (and made it evident, that the final aim was to subdue whole Finland).
By attacking Finland, Stalin lost the best chance of securing the north-western border(Leningrad and Murmansk RR) by a NEUTRAL state. The hard terms of the Moscow Peace Treaty, and the additional demands and pressure applied after the war, threw Finland into the arms of Germany.

....and when looking at the gains of the war for the SU ("securing Leningrad" on the Isthmus), what was it's worth during the Barbarossa?
- The naval base in Hanko lost it's importance when Wehrmacht took Estonia
- The Finnish Army conquered back the territories lost, and DID NOT advance (in the Isthmus) further south to threat Leningrad.
- a hostile Finland tied up scores of divisions, which could've been a bit more useful against the Germans in the south

Wed Mar 29 17:47:45 2000


Back to page 

AndyW Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
 AndyW re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 31)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 31)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Apr, 1)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Apr, 1)
 Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
Scott Fraser re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
David Glantz re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
 Tero Maybe out of context, but... (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
David Glantz re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Scott Fraser re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Tero Territorial aspirations (Mar, 26)
Scott Fraser re: Territorial aspirations (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Tero Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Albert re: Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Tero re: Soviet failure (Mar, 28)
Kostia re: Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Tero Please ellaborate (Mar, 28)
Kostia re: Please ellaborate (Mar, 28)
Tero re: Please ellaborate (Mar, 29)
Scott Fraser re: Soviet failure (Mar, 29)
Tero A Pyrhian victory ? (Mar, 29)
  •  Sami re: A Pyrhian victory ? (Mar, 29)
    Tero A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
     Sami re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
    Tero re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
     Sami re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
  •  Kostia re: Soviet failure (Mar, 29)
    Tero Losses and boozing (Mar, 30)
     Heino re: Losses and boozing (Mar, 30)
    Tero No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
     Heino re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
    Heino re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Kostia re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Kostia How come? (Mar, 31)
    Tero re: How come? (Mar, 31)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Sami re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Mikhail re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
    Sami ....counting the bodies.... (Mar, 31)
     Tero Joint Russo-Finnish research (Mar, 31)
    Jari Lievonen Winter War losses (Mar, 31)
     Heino re: To Tero (Mar, 31)
     Mikhail re: To Tero (Mar, 31)
    Robert A. Mosher re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
    Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
     Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Jorge Visca re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
    Scott Fraser re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
    Albert re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
    Mikhail re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
     Kostia re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)

    Records: 83

    Threads navigation:  142 <<<  141  >>> 140