Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Scott Fraser:
re: Answer

The way I understand you is that despots and dictators are stupid�
You�d better read it again. Neither Stalin nor Hitler were stupid, and I�ll thank you not to put words into my mouth. You obviously don�t understand my point. Both men were shunned by the democracies, who objected to the ideologies they professed, and to the manner in which they ran their countries. Both dictators were extremely practical men, pragmatic is a better word, and would have happily concluded a deal that would serve both their interests. After all, they did just that over Poland.

First of all I really doubt that Stalin wanted to share power with Hitler, as a friend.
I never said that, either. I said that they would have made a deal with each other if it served both their interests. They would have been content to share Europe, although you�re quite right, sooner or later they would have fallen out and war would have resulted. Both were greedy men.

Now about friends. To say now that 240 million people hated Stalin or even compare him to Milosevic is absolute BS. Pardon my French. Believe it or not people adored Stalin. YES THEY DID!!! Of course some saw him as a ruthless leader but many loved him. It was a strange phenomena. I talked to my grandparents about it, and they all told me that they cried on the day he died. They thought that the world was over. For us right now it's hard to understand but 60 years ago it was not. It was different. Actually Soviet Union was not made of only the Russians, actually a half of it was made of other nationalities.
I did not say 240 million people hated him. You said that 240 million people loved him, which is an asinine assertion. I live in Canada, but during the 1980s I worked several years aboard Soviet ships, alongside people from all over the Sojuz. I have many friends who are Georgian, Ukrainian, Kalmyk, Azerii, Armenian, Chechen, Kazakh, and from other national groups. Privately, they were willing to share quite ...

>>> 

Wed Mar 29 16:14:41 2000


Back to page 

Albert Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
Scott Fraser re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
Mike Jasinski re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)
Albert re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)
 Valera Potapov re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)
 Nick re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 27)
Kostia re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 27)
 Valera Potapov re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 28)
Kostia re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 28)
 Greg Leon Guerrero re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 31)
 Kostia re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 31)
Jeff Some more thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 28)
Scott Fraser re: Readings (Mar, 29)
Mikhail Question to Scott (Mar, 27)
Scott Fraser re: Answer (Mar, 29)
 Mikhail re: Answer (Mar, 29)
  • Scott Fraser re: Answer (Mar, 29)
    Fred re: Answer (Mar, 29)
    Scott Fraser re: Answer to Fred (Mar, 30)
    Fred re: Answer to Scott (Mar, 30)
    Mikhail re: Answer to Scott (Mar, 30)
  • Kostia re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)

    Records: 24

    Threads navigation:  148 <<<  147  >>> 146