Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Tero:
re: Please ellaborate

>Geez, I've explained to somebody.

Not to me. Sorry :-)

>I'm not fully into the topic (only one full books concerning only about Winter war), the facts about 25 days, were given to me during a discussion about Winter war, by a proffesor, who specialises himself in Northern countries. He explained that the actual Mannerheim line (a very round explanation I agree), was passed by the RKKA in 25 days, the rest of the fortifications, were not considered as the line, but later, they were thrown into one box.

A very general explanation from a man of his caliber and expertise I must say.

The term "Mannerheim line" and what it entails is a matter of semantics, I agree. But the fact is the term was concocted for the foreing press (or even BY the foreign press) when they wanted to know what the "line" was called. The actual defensive installations were constructed from the -20's onwards so some of the installations were almost 20 years old by 1939. The installations were constructed with defence in debth was in mind (kinda sort-of) and there were installations for a second and a third line of defence. Because the construction of the line had not been a co-ordinated effort (due to shoestring defence budget's of the -30's) there were no real interlocking fields of fire to speak of. The "line" was in effect as string of independed bunkers and strong points connected with dugouts.

On a related note: There was free access to the installations and during the war highly detailed maps of the installations were found from captured and fallen Russian officers. The Soviet claim that the line was as strong as the Maginot Line is bogus and they know it themselves very well.

The "passed by the RKKA in 25 days" argument is also (in my oppinion) VERY inaccurate. First of all (as I have pointed out earlier) it took a lot more time to penetrate the line, even if we are talking only about the first line of defence. Second: the line was not "passed by". The eastern sector of the line held the entire 105 days of the war. The southern sector was breached and even then I would hesitate to use the term "pass by" as it was rough going for the RKKA all the way until the end of hostilities.

Wed Mar 29 12:12:41 2000


Back to page 

AndyW Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 24)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
 AndyW re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 31)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 31)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Apr, 1)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Apr, 1)
 Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 29)
 Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 30)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
Scott Fraser re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
David Glantz re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
 Tero Maybe out of context, but... (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 25)
David Glantz re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Scott Fraser re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Tero Territorial aspirations (Mar, 26)
Scott Fraser re: Territorial aspirations (Mar, 29)
 Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
Tero Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Albert re: Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Tero re: Soviet failure (Mar, 28)
Kostia re: Soviet failure (Mar, 27)
Tero Please ellaborate (Mar, 28)
Kostia re: Please ellaborate (Mar, 28)
  • Tero re: Please ellaborate (Mar, 29)
  • Scott Fraser re: Soviet failure (Mar, 29)
    Tero A Pyrhian victory ? (Mar, 29)
     Sami re: A Pyrhian victory ? (Mar, 29)
    Tero A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
     Sami re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
    Tero re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
     Sami re: A few more weeks (Mar, 30)
     Kostia re: Soviet failure (Mar, 29)
    Tero Losses and boozing (Mar, 30)
     Heino re: Losses and boozing (Mar, 30)
    Tero No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
     Heino re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
    Heino re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Kostia re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Kostia How come? (Mar, 31)
    Tero re: How come? (Mar, 31)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Sami re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
     Mikhail re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 30)
    Tero re: No fiction, just facts (Mar, 31)
    Sami ....counting the bodies.... (Mar, 31)
     Tero Joint Russo-Finnish research (Mar, 31)
    Jari Lievonen Winter War losses (Mar, 31)
     Heino re: To Tero (Mar, 31)
     Mikhail re: To Tero (Mar, 31)
    Robert A. Mosher re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
    Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 26)
     Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Valera Potapov re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Max re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
     Mikhail re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Kostia re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 27)
    Jorge Visca re: Suvorov's credibility? (Mar, 28)
    Scott Fraser re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
    Albert re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
    Mikhail re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)
     Kostia re: Destruction of fortifications (Mar, 29)

    Records: 83

    Threads navigation:  142 <<<  141  >>> 140