Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Bob Mackenzie:
re: M4 Sherman's in USSR

1. When were the M4�s first sent to the USSR?

Dear James

OK briefly...

1) I'm not 100% probably in 1942 with 1st combat early 43?

2) 2. How did the Soviets use the M4�s? What types of roles were they given? Were they successful in these roles? What
opinion did the Soviets form of the M4�s?

The Soviets liked the M-4, especially the 76mm version. At least one Gds tank Corps traded in its T-34/85 for Sherman 76. Mostly the Soviets prised it for its reliability, though there were problems with its rubber road wheels

3. Did the US send any military observers along with their shipments of M4�s to see how the Soviets chose to utilize the M4�s?

Yes they sent technical advisors IIRC

4. Did the US send any military observers to study Soviet armored tactics in general, to learn from the Eastern Front veterans
before engaging the Germans in France?

More likely they used Britsh experience from the Desert

5. Finally, of the other lend lease tanks sent to the Soviets, did they form a much more positive or negative opinion of any other
tanks? I know that the Valentine and the M3 Lee were also sent to the Soviets. Were any other tanks delivered in large
numbers?

Matildas, Valentines and Churchils (6pdr) were supplied by the brits. M-3 Light tanks, M-3 Mediums (Lee) and Shermans supplied by the US

Didn't like the Matilda skow & undergunned, Churchil was better by still undergunned. Loved the Valentine as they though of it as a light tank. It was reliable and much heavier armoured than the T-70 with an equivalent gun

M-3 light was critsised for being under armoured & undergunned. The Lee was called the Grave for 6 brothers - go figure!

Cheers

Bob

Mon Mar 27 03:27:37 2000


Back to page 

 James Quinn M4 Sherman's in USSR (Mar, 25)
David Glantz re: M4 Sherman's in USSR (Mar, 25)
 Stephen Brezinski re: M4 Sherman's in USSR (Mar, 26)
  • Bob Mackenzie re: M4 Sherman's in USSR (Mar, 27)
     James Quinn re: M4 Sherman's in USSR (Mar, 27)
  • Records: 5

    Threads navigation:  143 <<<  142  >>> 141