Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Scott Fraser:
re: Some thoughts about Suvorov

I suggest rather than consider criticism based on reputations and credentials, look instead at the historical circumstances of 1941. It was not possible for the Red Army to sustain offensive operations against the Wehrmacht at that time because of deficiencies in material and leadership. The political realities of Russo-German relations in early 1941 would have not allowed planning to proceed � Stalin would have immediately stopped it, and probably shot whoever concocted the scheme. The absolute last thing he wanted to do was antagonize Hitler, his only "friend" in the world, and planning a pre-emptive attack on Germany would have been seen by the Germans as equivalent to a declaraion of war.

Mr.Suvorov's thesis is nonsense.

Sun Mar 26 16:28:01 2000


Back to page 

Albert Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
  • Scott Fraser re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
    Albert re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
    Albert re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 26)
    Mike Jasinski re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)
    Albert re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)
     Valera Potapov re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)
     Nick re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 27)
    Kostia re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 27)
     Valera Potapov re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 28)
    Kostia re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 28)
     Greg Leon Guerrero re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 31)
     Kostia re: Who Corroborates?? (Mar, 31)
    Jeff Some more thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 28)
    Scott Fraser re: Readings (Mar, 29)
    Mikhail Question to Scott (Mar, 27)
    Scott Fraser re: Answer (Mar, 29)
     Mikhail re: Answer (Mar, 29)
    Scott Fraser re: Answer (Mar, 29)
    Fred re: Answer (Mar, 29)
    Scott Fraser re: Answer to Fred (Mar, 30)
    Fred re: Answer to Scott (Mar, 30)
    Mikhail re: Answer to Scott (Mar, 30)
    Kostia re: Some thoughts about Suvorov (Mar, 27)
  • Records: 24

    Threads navigation:  148 <<<  147  >>> 146