| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
Here are some of my thoughts to defend Suvorovs thesis.I will point out arguments against Suvorov and then try to comment them.
At first-I have heard some sayings that because Suvorov was a defector he tries now to justify his "betrayal"(in my opinion then we can say also that von Stauffenberg was a traitor too),but they havent bothered to prove that Suvorov is wrong.
Most wide-spread is the argument that Suvorov isnt historian and no "respectable historian"dont agree with him.If Suvorov is historian or not that comes out if we prove that he is wrong or right,but the accusations that he isnt historian and because of that is wrong are ridiculous.
Now about "respectable historians".When did they earn their respect?My guess is that mostly during cold war.So if they researched Russo-German conflict,did they visit russian archives?Hell no!So what kind of an information did they get from Moscow?Surely only this kind of info what communists wanted to give.Now"respectable historians" have built their research atleast partially on this information.But lets pretend that Suvorov is right then what happens to respectable ones.Well their respect is probably gone,they have to admitt that they have been wrong.Those historians actually hasnt got no chance of retreat anymore because they have so fiercely opposed Suvorov.But their respect in my eyes starts to vanish if they continue to claim that Suvorov isnt right because he isnt "respectful historian".
Now Suvorov has been accused in that he abandons those facts that doesnt comply with his theories.
In my opinion if you have read Suvorovs books you can see that he always mentions counterclaims and he analyses them.Now lets take for example Mr.Glantzs "Stumbling Colossus",if you have read this you know that Mr.Glantz doesnt bother much to analyse Suvorovs mistakes.
In my opinion"respected historians"are those who are not seeing anything that contradicts their theories(like quotes from Soviet books,which does exist,but doesent ...
Sun Mar 26 14:31:25 2000