Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Scott Fraser:
re: Mr Glantz

I had the pleasure of listening to Mr. John Keegan speak at a Massey Lecture in 1996. One central theme of his speech was how English-language and German-language have shaped our perceptions of the Second World War. there were a couple of very interesting observations he made which are pertinent here.

Firstly, he mentioned the RNZAF, who fought alongside the US air forces throughout the Solomon Islands Campaign. They are never mentioned � not in American histories, because they are not American, and not in English histories because the Solomon Islands was outside the British "sphere" in the Far East, which did not extend beyond the indian Ocean. Winston Churchill neglected to mention the New Zealanders' contribution in his magnum opus dealing with the Second World War, and since most of the English-language histories have been based on this work, this error of omission has been perpetuated.

Secondly, he observed that since 1993, when scholars have been granted limited access to the NKVD/MVD/KGB archives in the Lyubyanka, it has emerged that Soviet Russia suffered casualties far beyond the relatively conservative estimates of 20 millions bandied about in the West. Personally, I always felt that this figure was far too low, and put the losses more towards 30 millions, which is to say, the present population of Canada. In point of fact, according to Mr. Keegan, the records would indicate that the actual number of military and civilian casualties was to the order of sixty millions, which is incredible, representing perhaps 25% of the 1940 population of the USSR. His point, finally, was that if we in the West could be so wrong about the scale of bloodletting in the USSR between 1941 and 1945, there are no doubt a good many other things we are just as wrong about. Food for thought.

Wed Mar 8 15:12:32 2000


Back to page 

 Path Mr Glantz (Mar, 6)
David Glantz re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 7)
Scott Fraser re: History vs Propaganda (Mar, 8)
 Greg Leon Guerrero re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 7)
Mike Jasinski re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 7)
 Forum Moderator re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 7)
Mike Jasinski re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 7)
  • Scott Fraser re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 8)
    David Glantz re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 8)
    Paul Lakowski Mike J. (Mar, 9)
     Greg Leon Guerrero re: Mike J. (Mar, 10)
    Claus B re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 14)
  • Records: 12

    Threads navigation:  108 <<<  107  >>> 106