Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

Mike Jasinski:
re: Mr Glantz

Path wrote:

>>Came across this rebuttal someone posted when another forum member cited your work in a debate on the SU in WWII. I
think its' a matter of some facts not fitting well in the posters preconceived notions. Anyway since I know you frequent the
RMZ here I thought you might be amused. The debate is here http://www.tankers.net/forum/showconf.asp?conf_index=1
titled 'Russia Defeated Germany in WWII' <<

I'm afraid I've had the dubious honor of having been the "another forum member" Path is referring to. I quoted a few works by David Glantz, John Ellis and Charles Sharp which give some idea of the magnitude of the struggle on the Eastern Front and got myself labelled a "fanatic" for doing so. Needless to say, I decided not to bother posting on that forum anymore. The fellow who tried to pin that label on me also happened to think von Mellenthin's "Panzer Battles" is an excellent source of information on fighting on the Eastern Front, which should give you some idea of the level of discussion.

Furthermore, if anyone wishes to post on that forum, he or she should be prepared to be ridiculed, misquoted, quoted out of context, or even have statements they never made attributed to them. I found dealing with all of the above (not to mention the occasional ad hominem attack, in spite of the fact it's supposed to be a moderated forum) more trouble than it's worth, even though it's probably only a small (but very vocal) minority of that forum's participants who engage in such tactics. So, be advised.

Regards,
Mike Jasinski

Tue Mar 7 08:18:15 2000


Back to page 

 Path Mr Glantz (Mar, 6)
David Glantz re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 7)
Scott Fraser re: History vs Propaganda (Mar, 8)
 Greg Leon Guerrero re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 7)
  • Mike Jasinski re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 7)
     Forum Moderator re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 7)
    Mike Jasinski re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 7)
    Scott Fraser re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 8)
    David Glantz re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 8)
    Paul Lakowski Mike J. (Mar, 9)
     Greg Leon Guerrero re: Mike J. (Mar, 10)
    Claus B re: Mr Glantz (Mar, 14)
  • Records: 12

    Threads navigation:  108 <<<  107  >>> 106