Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Veenenberg:
re: German War casulties East-Front

On the first issue: maybe there was no policy but then there was a praxis to shoot captured enemy soldiers: remind you that quite from the start of Barbarossa the Soviets shot virtually every German which was captured. Feodosia etc. The farther the war progressed and the more Germans surrendered reletively less Germans were shot. In Berlin one Soviet soldier admitted that he alone shot 20 members of the Waffen-SS in the head after they surrendered!!! Revenge for so many attrocities in the Soviet Union: he lost 10 members of his family.
With successes I intentionally referred to the heavy wounded also included in the casualty list. Then Bagration was NO success!!! Almost 800.000 Soviet casualties versus 375.000 German.
(Krivosheev). He also presented higher Soviet casualties in the Kishinev operation. Personally the numbers you gave may be also true. In the whole battle of Berlin Germans lost 200.000 troops and the Soviets about 300.000. But also many German civilians were killed or wounded.
We agree: statistics have parameters (time span, area). Most parameters doesn't fit when comparing given numbers of a side.
I strongly advise you to study David Glantz latest bestseller: The Battle of Kursk. He presents statistics which can be compared and he also presents the whole story to evaluate those statistics. A masterpiece!!!!

Thu Mar 2 20:28:47 2000


Back to page 

 Veenenberg German War casulties East-Front (Feb, 27)
Max Fedorov re: German War casulties East-Front (Feb, 27)
 Veenenberg re: German War casulties East-Front (Feb, 28)
Max Fedorov re: German War casulties East-Front (Feb, 29)
 Veenenberg re: German War casulties East-Front (Feb, 29)
Max Fedorov re: German War casulties East-Front (Feb, 29)
 CPaige Canada re: German War casulties East-Front (Mar, 1)
Max Fedorov re: German War casulties East-Front (Mar, 2)
 Veenenberg re: German War casulties East-Front (Mar, 1)
Max Fedorov re: German War casulties East-Front (Mar, 2)
  •  Veenenberg re: German War casulties East-Front (Mar, 2)
    Max Fedorov re: German War casulties East-Front (Mar, 3)
     R. Veenenberg re: German War casulties East-Front (Mar, 5)
  •  Stephen Brezinski re: Russian casualties (Mar, 3)
    Alex Wood re: Russian casualties (Mar, 5)

    Records: 15

    Threads navigation:  96 <<<  95  >>> 94