Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Max Fedorov:
Controversy with 29 ID (motorized) in November 1942

Most German sources I've read say that the 29 ID (motorized) during the initial phase of the battle of Stalingad inflicted a sharp reverse on the Russian 57th Army and the XIII mechanized Corps, when these were driving to Kalach.
The best Soviet account on the battle, Samsonov's Stalingradskay Bitva, says quite the contrary. Samsonov says the German Corps suffered heavy casualties and after some seesaw battles retreated behind Chervlionaya river. This book even says that 52 whole panzers with their crews were captured by the Russians. Does anybody know where some more reliable information on this episode can be found?

Mon Feb 21 20:58:04 2000


Back to page 

  •  Max Fedorov Controversy with 29 ID (motorized) in November 1942 (Feb, 21)
     Veenenberg re: Controversy with 29 ID (motorized) in November 1942 (Feb, 23)
     Daniel Olsson How do you know? (Feb, 24)
     Veenenberg re: How do you know? (Feb, 27)
     Michi OOB & TOE of PzAbt 129/29. ID(mot): (Mar, 1)
  • Records: 5

    Threads navigation:  89 <<<  88  >>> 87