| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
I do appreciate learning the additional details you provided in the follow up. Thanks much. Unfortunately I haven't picked Temkin's book up yet.
The problem you raised is indeed a challenging one. A provocation in the best sense of the word.
My guess at this stage, based upon the fact that Temkin was definite about things, is that his raidering detachment had just been issued a new type of Avtomat, namely Sudayev's PPS-43. That explanation definitely fits the scenario as you know that this weapon had certain teething problems in addition to a relatively late start in gaining full, serial production. When units outside of Leningrad Front received these automatic carbines they invariably gave rave reviews. Even the "man" himself, Mikhail Timofayevich is quoted as saying: "It can be said in all seriousness that A.I. Sudayev's submachine gun, created and issued to the Red Army beginning in 1942, was the best submachine gun of the World War II period. Not one foreign design could be compared with it in simplicity of construction, reliability, durability in function, and ease of use. Airborne troops, tankers, scouts, partisans, and ski troops loved the Sudayev weapon for its high tactical-technical and combat qualities, combined with its small dimensions and weight." (translated and quoted by James F. Gebhard as extracted from D. N. Bolotin's ISTORIYA SOVETSKOGO STRELKOVOGO ORUZHIYA I PATRONOV).
Does this sound reasonable to you, Nick? BTW, its a pleasure meeting a fellow shooter at this forum. Keep 'em in the X-ring.
Tue Jan 18 20:23:26 2000