Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Richard Gould:
Simonov Carbines in Action

Nick, I've looked into the same historical problem of who, when, and where relating to battlefield use of Simonov self loading carbines.

Altho we agree Temkin -- in all likelihood -- was confusing the SKS with the AK, we might disagree that the report of use on River Prut, March 1944, is not credible. That seems too early a date and too unlikely a place yet much stranger things happen. Besides AKs were held as top secret devices well into the 1950s and so it is unlikely that Temkin had the opportunity of being issued a serial production model.

The 78th Zaparozhye Rifle Division was not a particularly likely candidate to try these handy carbines out. Yet, again, we can't be sure. A better bet would have been a division facing one of the more far flung and isolated German outposts in Byelorussia, say somewhere on the east bank of the Dneipr River, in June of 1944, where chances of a Nazi capture of one or more working samples would have been minimal or nil. That is what I've suspected happened, but ...

By 1945, the Hitlerites did indeed have Simonov selfloading carbines, chambered in the 7.62mm M-1943 service cartridge, among their war trophies. They issued a technical intelligence document on the SKS for their troops to read.

Great questions, Nick. Unfortunately, hard facts are near nonexistant at this point. Perhaps this year we'll learn more.

Tue Jan 18 06:37:39 2000


Back to page 

 NICK""""""" Proto-Kalashnikov (Jan, 17)
  •  Richard Gould Simonov Carbines in Action (Jan, 18)
     NICK re: Simonov Carbines in Action (Jan, 18)
     Richard Gould Avtomats in Action (Jan, 18)
     NICK re: Avtomats in Action (Jan, 18)
     Tero Just a thought... (Jan, 19)
     NICK re: Just a thought... (Jan, 19)
     NICK re: oooops! (Jan, 19)
     lev re: Proto-Kalashnikov (Feb, 5)
     Damian Czerniewicz re: Proto-Kalashnikov (Feb, 25)
  • Records: 10

    Threads navigation:  42 <<<  41  >>> 40