Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Gary M. Frank:
re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack?

Hi Nick

The initial comments regarding Stalin were purely speculation. No one really knows what he really felt. As far as my comments regarding the Germans. I was refering to their tactical conduct during the opening stages of the campaign. The popular believe that the German plans were executed flawlessly isn't true. Many company and battalion were inexperienced, and coupled with over confidence, lead to stupid tactical mistakes. Operationally however, the coordination with air and ground forces, and the German Command structure, made those mistakes less noticable.

I'm not saying that the German tactics were bad over all. They were as ready for Barbarossa as they were going to be. However, if Stalin had prepared himself for the German onslaught, he could have "again speculation" saved a larger part of his army, fallen back to better possitions, and possibilly stopped the German offensive sooner. Or at least held the front further west until winter.

Just a thought....Cheers
GMFrank

Tue Jan 4 20:55:34 2000


Back to page 

 Greg Leon Guerrero Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Dec, 31)
 Brad Rivera re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
 Greg Leon Guerrero re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
 .NICK.. re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
 Greg Leon Guerrero re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 5)
 Gary M. Frank re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
 .NICK.. re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
  •  Gary M. Frank re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
  • HAOster re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Feb, 22)

    Records: 9

    Threads navigation:  27 <<<  26  >>> 25