Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Gary M. Frank:
re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack?

Nicely put Brad.

Another fact that would help support your theory is, after the invasion, Stalin disappaered as if in total denial of the current situation. Who knows maybe he was actually "praying" that the reports from the front were false.

Here's another question that might interrest you.

If Stalin had reacted differently, could the Soviet forces have checked or even stopped the German invasion?

I have a few books from the Center of Military History. Most of the information is from after action reports written by the German commanders criticing themselves and their troops perfomance. From what the information I have gathered, it seems that the tactical performance of the Soviets was better than that of the Germans. Remeber, the Germans were over confident and had no reason to believe that the Russians with stand the Blitzkrieg. As for the Russian Army. They were defending their homeland, and eventhough they were able to slow down the German advance in some areas, their command structure did not allow the local commanders to coordinate operations without STAVKA approval. i.e. Opperationally the Germans were better which made up for their tactical mistakes.

Just a little food for thought...Cheers.
GMFrank

Tue Jan 4 18:16:40 2000


Back to page 

 Greg Leon Guerrero Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Dec, 31)
 Brad Rivera re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
 Greg Leon Guerrero re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
 .NICK.. re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
 Greg Leon Guerrero re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 5)
  •  Gary M. Frank re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
     .NICK.. re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
     Gary M. Frank re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Jan, 4)
  • HAOster re: Did Stalin really think they wouldn't attack? (Feb, 22)

    Records: 9

    Threads navigation:  27 <<<  26  >>> 25