Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Pentti Perttula:
re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war

Thanks for the prompt response, Valera.

You won't be able to make conclusions of the maximum number of losses with the monthly average number of men, if you don't know the number of men that arrived as replacements during those months. This doesn't mean that I would agree with Hrustshev's calculations, but I disagree those from different reasons.

Do you believe that there is a reliable source that has unaltered data, when we speak about the losses of the enemy or friendly troops? I recall the Soviet statistics of Finnish aircraft losses in the Winter War that were 4 to 5 times higher than the actual losses.

But instead of talking of the total number of losses, we could split the problem in smaller units, i.e. battles & offensives, that may shed light to the total number. I understand that there are casualties beyond the battles, f.ex. bombings, frost bitten etc., but if the "Killed In Action" counted from the separate battles were tens of thousands, it would be hard to believe that there are hundreds of thousands that died on the battle field. Do you have this kind of statistics published in Russia? I have the Finnish official history of the Winter War that tries to calculate the Soviet losses, too, but I don't know how far it records the Soviet losses per battle. I may take a look in the near future.

Regards,

Pentti

Tue Jan 4 14:17:41 2000


Back to page 

 Scott Shuford Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 29)
 Juhis J re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 29)
 M. D. Fox re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 30)
 Gareth Collins re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 30)
 Juhis J re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 30)
 Scott Shuford re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 30)
 ... 1 million! Are you sure! (Jan, 2)
 Valera Potapov re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 30)
 Roman Khrapachewsky re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 31)
 Pentti Perttula re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Jan, 3)
 Valera Potapov re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Jan, 3)
 Tero re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Jan, 4)
  •  Pentti Perttula re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Jan, 4)
  • Records: 13

    Threads navigation:  23 <<<  22  >>> 21