Forum Archive #3

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct

 Valera Potapov:
re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war

"Valera, you give the total number of the men in the invading force, but is that really the total number or is it only the number time in the beginning of the war?"

No, that weren't a total number of invading force but a montly average strenght of the Red Army.

"Has anyone really checked the figures of the KIAs and WIAs in the Winter War battle by battle?"

I haven't a big experience in english abbreviations, what are the "KIA" and "WIA" mean? I suppose KIA=killed and WIA=wounded. Am I right?
As to your question, the information about losses usually takes from various after-battle reports. I don't know hot it WAS verified (if any) and how it can be verified TODAY. So, I tend to agree the exact number of KIA and WIA won't be find, at the same time the difference between Khrushev's and Krivosheev's data too big. Since I know Krivosheev's sources and don't know Khrushev's one, I will accept Krivosheev's figures.

Mon Jan 3 21:38:37 2000


Back to page 

 Scott Shuford Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 29)
 Juhis J re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 29)
 M. D. Fox re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 30)
 Gareth Collins re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 30)
 Juhis J re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 30)
 Scott Shuford re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 30)
 ... 1 million! Are you sure! (Jan, 2)
 Valera Potapov re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 30)
 Roman Khrapachewsky re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Dec, 31)
 Pentti Perttula re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Jan, 3)
  •  Valera Potapov re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Jan, 3)
     Tero re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Jan, 4)
     Pentti Perttula re: Soviet losses in 1939-40 winter war (Jan, 4)
  • Records: 13

    Threads navigation:  23 <<<  22  >>> 21