| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
I won't even try to make a conclusion, but let's summarize the figures stated so far:
Author KIA WIA Total(incl.MIAetc)
C. van Dyke 131,476 325,000 456,476
A. Werth (?) 65,384 186,584 251,968
"western view" 200,000 ? ?
"Finnish estim" 200,000 900,000 1,100,000
"official fig" 48,747 158,864 207,611
Krivosheev 71,214 188,671 391,783
Hrustsev ? ? 1,000,000
Quite a variety! I can still add another one: according to Juha Ilo & Jason Pipes, at German Armed Forces in WWII Site, Wehrmacht studies (in 1941) estimate Soviet losses in Winter War as 273,000 killed and 800,000 wounded.
Valera, you give the total number of the men in the invading force, but is that really the total number or is it only the number time in the beginning of the war? What I mean is that the losses were usually replaced by fresh men, so the losses could be bigger than the actual number of men in a unit at a point of time. F.ex. the losses for certain platoons of the U.S. 90th Inf. Div. were 200 per cent as they fought their way from the Normandy to the Rhine.
Has anyone really checked the figures of the KIAs and WIAs in the Winter War battle by battle? IMO that would give a better foundation to work from. I may try to do that, if I ever find the time.
Regards,
Pentti
Mon Jan 3 11:43:47 2000