Rommel not a good commander? I have to jump on this one. Considering that he was sent to N. Africa to save the Italians from defeat with limited equipment, to do what he accomplished, says a great deal about his ability. He did the best he could with equipment that was not designed for desert combat and a supply system that was shaky at best. The British Air Force controlled the Med shipping routes. If he would have been given the resources that Guderian had in France and during Barbarossa, he could have taken Egypt from Montgomery and changed the face of the war.