Gareth,with all due respect,I disagree with your assesment of Rommel......Hitler relegated the Desert front to one of secondary importance compared to the EAST.....certainly out of necessity,however,Rommel was never supplied adequately to sustain the tactical gains achieved by Panzer Army Africa...This supply situation became worse when the Royal Navy and RAF took control of the Mediteranean and the failure of the Germans to neutralize Malta.......On the other hand,Montgomery waited until he had overwhelming superiority in all arms before(you have to give him credit for this)attempting a major attack....This is another"what if",but if Rommel was supplied as well as Army Group South was at the outset I believe he would have taken Egypt,and swept the British from N.Africa with obvious consequences......Keep up the good work,GARETH