re: Soviet Union, savior of the Allies? Lend lease?
>I am having an argument with several Finnish >historians about the Western lend lease to >Soviet Union in WWII. My opinion is that >Soviets actually destroyed the German war >machine
Number of lend-lease tanks was not that important but what was important were trucks and APC's. Red army failed in almost all of it's attacks prior to latter half of 1943 mainly because their SUPPLIES FAILED completely. Even the pursuit after Stalingrad failed partly because of this. Red Army had to rely on capturing at least some German fuel and food during the advance in order to keep going. Some major operations were actually planned to go from one German depot to an other (BTW, it is interesting to note that the Germans did the same in Ardennes in 1944 exactly for same reason: no transportation capacity to bring all the fuel to the front. Solution: capture american fuel depots on the way)
When the american trucks and APC's were available in sufficient numbers all this changed and the Russian war machine became much more mobile. Now it was possible to start banging the German front with the full weight of the sledge hammer and even start attacks almost simultaneously in diffrent sectors of the front.
It is anybodys guess what would have happened without Western help. But it was significant and it allowed Soviet Union to allocate her resources into production of armour and aeroplanes. Lost of food and raw materials (especially cloth and certain metallurgic producst) plus transportation was provided by the Americans and the British.
My five cents worth,
Jari Lievonen
PS. Differece in opinion is not the same as a lie. Your teachers may have a case but I am certain that they will be happy to discuss it with you given that you have facts to support your view. At least that was the purpose when I was studying.