Thanks for the info George. With regard to the I-14, I believe that you are right when you state that Sukhoi was the designer but that he was working in the Tupolev OKB rather than independently at the time. Are you saying that the IP-1 was still in use for home defence at the time of WW.II or had they been withdrawn by this date?. In the case of both designs I make the assumption that after withdrawl from first line use they were passed to training units-but this is pure guesswork,based on the fact that this often happened to former front line machines in other airforces. Can anyone confirm or refute this supposition?