Thats true.However,by the time the IS-2 was in service they pretty much did.The PAnzer IV's,Tigers and Panthers certainly all had them.The Stugs did as well and so did most of the tank destroyers in service.
"A pre-war tanks (most of them armed with 45mm or short barreled 76mm guns) were designed for combat on a quite short ranges - usually 300-500 meters. Soviet optic allowed that. Do you really need of an optic sight which possibility is much better then gun accuracy? Again, Soviet optic WAS ADEQUATE to the possibility of Soviet guns!"
I agree mostly with what you're saying here.Early soviet optics certainly were adequate to handle the most typical encounters.There were plenty of engagements over the 300-500 meter range you refer to though.Post war studies showed that about 60-65% of Tank vs Tank engagements took place at under 1000 meters.I believe about 30% took place between 1000-2000 meters with the remaining 5% taking place at distances over 2000 meters.
Most early war Tanks of Germany and the Soviet Union(Early PZRIII's and IV's,with some czech tanks mixed in,against the T-26's and the BT's that comprised the majority of early war Soviet armored forces) were capable of knocking each other out at ranges over the 300-500m you talked about however.Yes the guns certainly were much less powerfull than those used later in the war,but then tank armor was much thinner as well.In those situations where engagements were over 500m,which werent all that uncommon, the German tanks would have the edge.
On the other hand,it wasnt all that uncommon for T-34's or KV's to make an appearance either.In which case the German edge in Tank optics was completely nullified,due to an inability to penetrate at the longer ranges their optics allowed hits to be acheived.
This discussion certainly has gotten off track.It wasnt my intention at all to in any way start knocking Soviet armor.I was just attempting to give some reasons why there werent more accounts of IS-2 success in Tank vs Tank enagagements.Let me give a couple more reasons that that this may be so then I'll talk about the positive qualities-which is the reason I got in this discussion in the first place.I do like the tank.
The low ammo capacity-A fully loaded IS-2 would have only had around 14 AP projectiles.This is considerably lower than an opposing German tank would likely have had.Another reason is how the IS-2 was employed.It has been mentioned in this thread that it was used as a 'break through' tank.I think the term'break through'needs further clarification.The IS-2 was intended to break through weak points defended by infantry and artillery,not ground heavily defended by armor.From what I've read,the IS-2 was used in attacks primarily in an over watch role,and was used to shell soft targets ith its terrific HE rounds.Its secondary role was as a 'fire brigade',to counter attacks by German heavy tanks.
So,the role in which the IS-2 was primarily employed would have made Tank vs Tank engagements unlikely and in its secondary role,going against German heavy tanks,it had no easy task.
Let me give some qualities that I like specificly about the IS-2 and soviet armor in general from WW2.
The terrific Armor protection on the Glacis of the IS-2M,virtually impenatrable to the Germans unless one of those near mythical APCR rounds was available.
That 122mm gun.Anything short of a KingTiger or a JagdTiger,what it hits it kills.I've seen some of the most amusing debates centered on how the 122mm gun cant penetrate a Panther Glacis plate or this or that turret of whichever German tank happens to be in question.'Hole punching' ability isnt the only thing to take into account of an AP round.The 25kg shell was so large,and hit with such force and momentum,it didnt have to penetrate to knock out a German AFV.It could knock turrets right off their turret rings,flip a vehicle over or cause complete fracturing and failure of armor plate much thicker than it could punch a hole through(The Soviet 152mm guns were even better in this regard).And if the round didnt manage to do any of these things it could still cause tremendous spalling.And in most combat engagements the optics were completely adequate to acheive hits at the ranges involved.
That they were produced in relatively large numbers to German Heavy Tanks.An IS-2 may have been inferior in some important respects to Germany heavy Tanks,but for every German Panther or tiger there were likely to be 3 or more IS-2's and quantity certainly does have a quality all its own.The same goes for all Soviet AFV production in WW2-what the Soviets acheived production wise,especially after considering the beating they took early in the war,was an extremely impressive acheivement in my opinion.They dramaticly out planned and out produced the Germans,who controlled most of Europe for a large portion of the war.
The superior automotive reliability and ease of maintenance of Soviet AFV's.
The brave and creative crews of the Soviet AFV's,much like their American and British counterparts,who overcame certain technical disadvantages with guts and tactics and won armor battles nonetheless.