Routes chosen for the US Highway System reflected the population and politics of 1920's America. US 1 ended up running through the state capitols of Virginia, North Carolina and South Carolina as opposed to hugging the Atlantic coast. US 30, US 40 and US 50 were split into North and South branches by commmunities worried about being off the main route. The route chosen for US 48 was south of US 40. As hindsight is easier than foresight, I have wondered how I would renumber the system.
a1015taco has thought about it enough to set out a plan, as follows:
US 1) The new US 1 will start at the Canadian border like where it is now. Then, it will follow the current US 1 path to NYC, where it will pick up US 9. It will follow US 9 to US 13 in DE. Then, it will follow US 13 from DE to NC, where it will follow US 17 to US 1 in Jacksonville, FL. It will follow its current path to Key West, FL.
US 2) In this plan, I will connect the eastern leg, and western leg of US 2. It will start at its current starting point in Everett, WA. It will follow the current path all the way to St. Ignace, MI, where it will jump on I-75 south to US 23. Then, it will follow US 23 to MI-25 to MI-19. Then, it will pick up MI-3 to Dix Ave in Detroit, then Toledo Hwy in Detroit to US 24. Then, it will enter Ohio and pick up OH-2 to Sandusky, OH, where it will follow US 6. Then, it will reenter OH-2 in Cleveland to US 20. Next, it will pick up PA-5 to NY-5 to NY-179 near Lackawanna, NY. Then, it will take US 62 north to NY-61 to NY-18. Then, it will follow the shore of Lake Ontario to NY-104 in Rochester, NY. Then, after heading east on NY-104, it will turn north onto US 11. Then, it will take US 2 east to its current ending point in Houlton, ME.
US 3) Same route as current US 3.
US 4) Same route as current US 4.
US 5) US 5 will start at Derby Line, VT, like it does now. It will head south on US 5 to E. Windsor, CT. Then, it will duplex with I-91 across the CT River. It will exit at Exit 42 (the current CT-159). It will head south on CT-159 to Main St in Hartford. Next, it will follow Maple Ave to the Berlin Tnpk (CT-314) to its current route south to New Haven, CT.
US 6) The old US 6 is out of place for its whole length. This plan will solve it. First, it will start in Seattle, WA at WA-900. Next, it will parallel I-90 along WA-10. Then, it will hop on I-90 near Vantage, WA. Then, it will exit at Moses Lake and follow the parallel road to the north of it (no number shown on my NG atlas) to Exit 254. Then, it will duplex with I-90 to WA-904. Next, it will head north on US-195 into Spokane. Then, it will duplex with US 2 to ID-200 to MT-200. Next, it will duplex with I-90 to Garrison, MT, where it will pick up US 12. Then, it will duplex with I-94 to W. Fargo, ND. Next, it will follow US 10 to Minneapolis, where it will pick up I-694. It will head east on I-694 to US 61 north. It will then pick up US 8 to US 141 south to WI-57 to US 10. Then, it will cross Lake Michigan (via the current ferry or by a new bridge) to Ludington, MI. It will continue on US 10 to US 23. It will then duplex with I-75 to US 24 near Detroit. Then, it will enter Ohio and pick up OH-2 to Sandusky, OH, where it will follow US 6. Then, it will reenter OH-2 in Cleveland to US 20. It will continue east on US 20 to the end in Boston, MA. Note: I would really like it to follow the path of US 10 in the west, or paralleling I-90 or I-94.
US 7) Same route as current US 7.
US 8) US 8 would begin at the junction of US 10 and US 12 near St. Paul, MN. It would follow US 12 east to US 10 east, ending at WI-57 (new Route 6)
US 9) US 9 would begin at the Canadian border near Rouses Point, NY. It will continue south on US 9 to New York City, where it would pick up US 1 south. It will continue to Morrisville, PA, where it will follow US 13 south to the junction with the current US 9 (the new US 1).
US 10) US 10 will begin in Aberdeen, WA, at the junction of US 12 and US 101. It will head east on US 12 east to the old US 10 route in Montana from I-90 Exit 174 to I-94 Exit 93. Then, it will pick up US 12 east into ND, and SD into MN. Then, it will take US 10 east, starting in St. Paul, MN, to US 12 east in WI. Finally, it will continue on WI-16 to WI-190 to WI-145 to US 18 to a new ferry or bridge across Lake Michigan to South Haven, MI. Then, it will head along MI-43 to I-96 to MI-5 to Grand River Ave in Detroit to its terminus at the intersection with US 12 in Detroit.