John Howard Brown forwarded a delightful story about path-dependence and
railway track gauge that has been passed around the internet,
particularly among people in the Department of Defense and elsewhere
who bemoan outdated or bureaucratically oppressive "milspecs"--of which
gauge is cited as an ancient (and perhaps ridiculous) example.
Well, I've had an opportunity to look into the issue for my dissertation
(and forthcoming book), so perhaps I can clarify the record. As much as I
like the idea of path-dependence, and although I believe that I have shown
its applicability to the modern history of railway gauge, it seems unlikely
that we can carry the process back as far as the story suggests.
American railways were not built by ex-patriate Brits, but (almost
exclusively) by native American engineers who copied British practice.
This practice they copied was that of the Liverpool & Manchester Railway
(opened in 1830), built by mine-works engineer George Stephenson.
Stephenson indeed copied the gauge with which he had previous experience
in the mines, but this was originally the not quite so "exceedingly odd"
measure of 4'8". The extra half inch was added during construction of the
L&M in order to allow a little more leeway between rails and wheel flanges.
There is some evidence that the original rails were often 2" wide,
indicating a width of track including the rails of exactly 5'0"--still
less an "exceedingly odd" measure.
Mining tramways differed substantially in width, ranging mostly
between 3'0" and 4'6" in southern England and Wales. The 4'8" of northern
England was an outlier, and it is could be regarded as accidental that
Stephenson happened to have had a history with that gauge. It appears
true that mining ore carts were about the same width as road wagons,
but the width varied by region. It is plausible that the width of wagons
was fitted to road ruts, although ruts at narrow city gates might have
mattered more than ruts on open roads. The main "evidence" for carrying
the story back to Roman chariots, by the way, comes not from any study of
the history of road ruts but from consideration of ancient "groove-ways"--
essentially permanent stone "ruts", a practical form of improved road
surface at the time. It is true that one or two of these (NOT in Britain)
happen to have roughly the same "gauge" as modern railways--within a broad
band of wheel widths that would fit the grooves. However, others are of
different widths. So part of the story as told may be consistent with the
evidence, but it is hardly proved by it. (But if anyone knows of better
evidence, particularly any actual research on ruts, let me know.)
By the way--4'8.5" (1435 mm.) is the standard gauge in North America,
most of Europe (not in Iberia or former Russian and Soviet empires), and
parts of South America, Asia, and Australia. All told, nearly 60 percent
of world route length. The L&M railway had a strong demonstration effect
in Continental Europe as well as the U.S., and Stephenson-trained
engineers also aided the gauge's diffusion in Britain and the Continent--
but not in North America.
Again by the way--some American engineers copied Stephenson's practice
only approximately, doubtless in order not to deal with "exceedingly odd"
dimensions. Thus they introduced gauges of 4'9", 4'10", and 5'0". The
latter two choices led to some difficulties in later integrating the
continental railway network.
Douglas Puffert
University of Munich
This page last updated 4/17/01 3:52:14 PM