The General George A.Custer

George Custer: hero or villain?





George Custer was a Civil War herowhile still in his early 20s.



George Armstrong Custer gets a bum rap. And on his 123rd anniversary of his fabled "last stand", its time to consider his life and career.

Once portrayed by film star Errol Flynn as the embodiment of American manhood, popular culture-and,thus,the public mind- now views Custer as a brutal man who got what was coming to him.

Both images are false. Custer was a man whose vanity was compounded by his youth and whose tactical judgement was sometimes colouded by a desire to achieve a crushing victory at almost any cost. But he was not a psychopathic killer any more than he was a paragon.

Custer graduated last in his class at West Point in 1861 - but as historian Robert Utlley notes, he did graduate in an era when dropout rates were much higher that today.

He went on to a stellar career in the American Civil War, achieving a major-generalship while still in his early 20s. He was lionized by his men and feared by his Confederate foes.

Union Cavalry chief Phil Sheridan gave Custer's wife the table on which Robert E.Lee had signed his army's surrender out of respect for Custer's role in bringing about the Confereracy's defeat.

After the end of the Civil War , he reverted to his regular army rank of captain and serveed on patrol duty in Texas. Then only 25, he went from extraodinary headiness of high command and near-continous combat to parading horses around the Texas flatlands with soldiers who wanted nothing more, after years of war, to go home.

From being revered as a tenacious leader he bacame hated as an officious martinet.

In 1868, under orders from his superiors, he attcked a winter camp of Cheyennes along the Washita River in what is now Oklahoma. Most of those slain were women and children - although wen Custer was informed, by one of his officers, that non-combatants were being killed deliberatley, he ordered this stopped.

Attacking villages filled with women, children and the elderly was immoral - but it was also federal policy designed to defeat a highly mobile force.

Custer led an expedition into the Black Hills of what is now South Dakota - undisputed Sioux prpperty - in 1874. He brought along reporters and geologists, who together let the world know there was "gold in the grass roots".

This led to a stampede of miners into the Black Hills and ultimately to a U.S. policy to require all non-treaty Sioux to register at reservations.

Outragged that they had been ordered to comply with a treaty they had nevered signed, thousands of Sioux and Cheyenne gathered in southeast Montana and decided to stand against the coming forces of the U.S. military.

Traditionally when attacked, the Plains Indians dispersed and fled in an effort to protect non-combatants. When Custer attacked the large encampment along the banks of the Little Big Horn, he anticipated the same result.

This anticpation proved deadly wrong. After deviding his forces int three columns, Custer ordered one of them to attack the south end of the village with the promise that the column would attack from the east.

The south column, led by a panicky Major Marcus Reno, was repulsed and badly mauled. Viewing the size of the village for the first time from the bluffs above the river, Custer sent an urgent message to the third column, led by Captain Frederick Benteen, to come up quickly with the ammunition train. Benteen came accross Reno's ebattled command and stopped there.

Custers's men, according to Indian testimony and evidence of the battle field, fought with limited didiscipline. One Indian warrier years later entwined his fingers to show how confused was the fighting.

Dismounted the cavalry quickly lost their horses to the Indians, who swirled around them like a hurricane. The "last stand", on June 22, 1876, lasted no more than one hour as about 2,000 Sioux and Cheyennes killed every man in Custer's immediate command of about 210 men.

As senior commander, Custer holds ultimate blame for his defeat. Yet a carefield study of the battlefield reveals that he made sound tactical decisions in the disbursement of his men.

He did not expect his Indian adversaaries to fight with such ferocity or marshal such high numbers. He hoped for reinforcements that never arrived and was compelled to fight on ground wit no natural defensive cover. Nor did he expect his own men to fight so poorly.

Archeological findings show that Custer's men fired amazingly few bullets - a testimony to their fright, their rawness (many were new recruits) and the disorganization of the battle itself.

Demonization and sainthood are extremes history warns us generally to avoid. Custer is no execption. He was a generally capable American soldier executing his government's severe and often cruel Indian policy.

For this he deserves no great credit, but neither does he deserve unique condemnation.


This article was written by ROBERT SCWARZWALDER. Knight-Ridder Newspapers.
Printed in the MONTREAL GAZETTE on June 29, 1999


For more information or comments, E-mail: [email protected]