NOTE: The following article as well as "Nothing Personal" are made available to old time radio fans for non-commercial and/or reference purposes only. Permission for its re-distribution has been given for Lou Genco's old time radio WWW page only. For further information or to contact the author, contact BRC Productions. War in the Oxide Trenches By Robert D. Proctor Copyright (c) 1991 by Robert D. Proctor All rights reserved. Collecting old time radio programs is now assuming all the appearances of trench warfare all over The Shadow, a classic old time radio series which many collectors have held for years. Premier Electronics Laboratories of Sandy Hook, CT is lobbing legal mortar shells at nine veteran collector/dealers (and two small other companies) saying they infringed upon Premier's license from Conde Nast Publications of New York, the major conglomerate controlling The Shadow and its related properties. Premier filed suit on March 16, 1989, in U.S. District Court, District of Connecticut...only 136 days after signing its Shadow agreement with Conde Nast to manufacture and distribute home-usage recordings. Premier demanded damages of $100,000 from each defendant. Several Shadow defendants say that even one such damage demand exceeds the total gross OTR-sales income from all defendants. Until The Shadow lawsuit, selling old time radio shows was one of the most specialized niche markets of all commercial ventures...barely more than a handful of hobbyists helping other hobbyists. About 20 known collector/dealers serve about one U.S. resident in every 24,000 a fairly constant ratio since U.S. program collecting began on a widespread basis in the middle to late 1960s. The typical OTR vendor used standard domestic-style tape recorders, with sales profits usually barely enough to offset the vendor's own program trading costs. Many vendors lasted a year or less, while only a handful continued their businesses for more than a decade...many branching out into non-related fields but continuing their OTR sales in what many veteran collectors recognize as a genuine love of The Hobby. Most of these survivor vendors are now Shadow defendants: Don Aston, Rex Bills, Hal Brenner, Bob Burnham, Carl Froelich Jr., Charlie Garant, Dick Judge, Larry Kiner, and Pat McCoy. Named in separate Premier lawsuits were Stephen and Sharon Ferrante (Radio's Past) and Gary Rost (Wireless and Rivertown Trading, Inc., both loosely affiliated with Minnesota Public Radio). To simplify matters, the U.S. District Court combined these lawsuits under a single docket number (Aston's which was the first filed by Premier). What was not simple to understand was why an essentially mystery plaintiff had brought suit against these defendants, without first sending a cease and desist letter in a effort to halt their sale of contested material. To understand the importance of the cease and desist issue takes us to the man most collectors have long associated with The Shadow...Charles Michelson of Los Angeles, probably the senior rebroadcast syndicator in America. As events unfolded in court, it became known that Michelson no longer held the license to distribute The Shadow and here the real story behind the Shadow lawsuits began to take shape. Original Shadow owners were pulp-magazines giant Street & Smith Publishers, and Michelson (now age 84) held a truly genteel, Old School gentleman's handshake agreement with them. Michelson helped distribute The Shadow to subscribing stations, and after the series stopped production in 1954, Michelson entered the rebroadcast market, with an umbrella agreement allowing him to license individual radio stations, LP recordings and home- enjoyment tapes. Other powerhouse radio series he managed included The Green Hornet, The Lone Ranger, and Gangbusters. Michelson said Street & Smith gradually shrank in size as its owners grew older, and in 1961, S & S was finally sold to Conde Nast Publications, one of the more widely distributed magazine firms. Conde Nast publications include Vogue, House & Garden, Self, Bride's, Glamour, Mademoiselle, Gentlemen's Quarterly, Vanity Fair, Gourmet and the subscriptions-only Conde Nast Traveler. Conde Nast is at 350 Madison Ave., New York, NY 10017. As for Street & Smith, Michelson says, Conde Nast swallowed them whole. Until the S & S sale went through, he added, rebroadcast royalties from The Shadow went into an escrow account. And then his nearly fifty years' close association with The Shadow crumbled overnight. Conde Nast told me my licensing arrangement had expired, and I was out the door. Even more amazing to outside observers, Michelson says Conde Nast requested and received a list of all his Shadow franchisees, and in 1988 announced a bidding war among those former clients. Michelson's franchisees included The Mind's Eye, Metacom, and Radio Yesteryear. Metacom was prepared to bid more for the series, Michelson said, but they never got the chance. Conde Nast sold the rights to Radio Yesteryear. The CNP/Radio Yesteryear agreement was signed November 1, 1988, allowing Radio Yesteryear a five-year exclusive license to manufacture and distribute home-usage recordings, ending December 31, 1993. Issues and Players Probably no other company has caused greater controversy within hobbyist circles than Radio Yesteryear and its album subsidiary, Radiola. Founded by former collector J. David Goldin, Radio Yesteryear and Radiola were the first truly aggressively-marketed old time radio products. Goldin (a former engineer at CBS, NBC, and Mutual) relentlessly criss-crossed the U.S. in a grueling number of guest appearances on radio stations large and small. Off-the-air tape recordings of many such guest shots were later offered for sale in the Radio Yesteryear catalog. Goldin also was interviewed (with photo) in The National Enquirer. Clearly, there is nothing shy about J. David Goldin. His handsomely-produced 1971 Radio Yesteryear catalog listed ten Shadow programs for sale (with many others available ). But in 1973, a rubber-stamped message was added to these catalogs, saying Radio Yesteryear no longer sold copies of that series. Goldin denied in a 1973 letter that Michelson had anything to do with this, but did not elaborate. Later, however, Radio Yesteryear did acquire (non-exclusive) Michelson licensing to sell The Shadow...while meanwhile, Charles Michelson himself was quietly helping to reverse some long-held bitter feelings in hobbyist circles toward the merchandising of OTR. Hello Again (the longest surviving hobby newsletter), reported Michelson came to an October 1973 hobbyist conventions and spoke to a reportedly angry crowd of collectors. Hello Again said Michelson took the position that he had no objection to collectors who sell shows to other collectors. His one objection is against those who sell his copyrighted material to radio stations for commercial broadcast. This was, Michelson recalled in 1990, a live-and-let-live approach to marketing old time radio programs. He recognized that within the relatively small world of The Hobby, such sales were by the converted to the converted and the area in which his own business interest lay were rebroadcasting of programs to the civilian ( unconverted ) general radio listener. Michelson's live-and-let-live approach also extended to vendors who took Radio Yesteryear's example by advertising outside more traditional in-Hobby publications. One Shadow defendant said, I got a letter from Charlie that was a cease-and-desist letter over shows he thought I was selling to radio stations. I wrote back and assured him I was selling only to other collectors. That's the last I heard of it from him. Meanwhile, Radio Yesteryear continued to market its products exclusively outside the Hobby, at prices substantially higher than collector/dealers. A typical hour of Radio Yesteryear material sold for $10 to $12 (depending upon the intended marketing group), while collector/dealers charged the same prices for six hours of shows, on 1800-foot tape. Radio Yesteryear's pricing strategies incensed so-called purist OTR collectors who insisted that no collector had the right to sell programs...much less at Radio Yesteryear's going $10-$12/hour rates. Beginning collectors were among he staunchest defenders of mainstream collector/dealers, saying that without these vendors, the novice collector could not cheaply acquire programs at all. Hobbyist vendors in turn contended (and often proved) their sales were barely enough to underwrite their personal trading costs...and unlike any other area of memorabilia collecting and selling, these same hobbyist vendors were cheerfully steering their customers to Hello Again and similar Hobby magazines, even if it meant that a former client would stop buying material from them, as they got into their own trading activities. The issue of selling old time radio programs became a form of tribal warfare among hobbyists, and it affected almost no one...except civilians, people who bought LPs and tapes from nationally-advertised vendors...until they learned of lower-priced material within The Hobby (Later, in turn, many became avid traders, dropping their purchases of any kind.). Then the mid 1980s arrived, and with it a noticeable decline in what for years had been a live and let live attitude. Radiola issued a double album, The Story of the Shadow, featuring interviews with surviving key cast and crew members...as well as Michelson himself. The 1985 album-interview provided lengthy information of Michelson's long association with the series. In 1988, this former Michelson licensee assumed total control over home-usage recordings, and 136 days later fired off its first salvo of federal lawsuits. Charlie Garant says, I got the summons on a Friday night. The following Monday I shipped them my Shadow tapes and sent a money order for the full amount of the money involved $64.50. Nevertheless, Premier continued its demands for $100,000 from Garant, and the others. The lawsuit have targeted only those collector/dealers who had advertised outside of hobbyist publications. In stark contrast to Charles Michelson's approach, none of the Shadow defendants was first sent a cease-and-desist letter. This single issue continues to be the central source of puzzlement to all defendants contacted for this article. They repeatedly stress they would never knowingly violate anyone's legal rights to a given item. A simple cease-and-desist letter by any copyright holder would have led to immediate withdrawal of contested material. Larry Kiner, for example, withdrew The Cinnamon Bear, The Saint, and The Hall of Fantasy. Based on rumors alone that someone might object also withdrew Abbott & Costello. The same for any Arch Oboler material, Kiner said. I do not want to offend any legitimate owner. Obviously, I would have done the same regarding The Shadow, had anyone had the courtesy to ask! Co-defendant Bob Burnham agreed, in his article, A New Legal Problem for the OTR Dealer, in The Illustrated Press. Burnham said the collector/dealers would have immediately retreated on sales of any contested material with Burnham adding he would have even surrendered his master tapes, if necessary. Like Garant, however, the other Shadow defendants all contend their actual sales have been minimal. The best reason offered: The Shadow was traded out, much too widely-distributed among general hobbyists. The 43 Shadow shows I copied during the [136 days] were more than I usually did in a year, Garant recalls. In fact, when I was rounding up the tapes to send to Premier, I found some that had been packed away for several years. The Shadow was not a hot item. Then the mystery behind Premier Electronics' demand for $100,000 for each defendant began to clear up, once its ties to Radio Yesteryear became known. Then, as it became known that Premier Electronics now owned Radio Yesteryear, a few of the missing pieces in the Shadow defendants' puzzle began to fall into place. A Case of Trademarks Premier's Shadow lawsuit complaint states one of its attorneys had been admitted to the U.S. District Court in connection with Premier's 1985 suit in the California District, against Donald L. Aston and Aston's Adventures. Aston's main catalog bore the title Yesterday's Radio on Tape, which Premier alleged Aston had infringed upon its Radio Yesteryear trademark. In 1987, the California District federal judge ruled there had been no infringement. It is at that juncture (several observers say) that Premier Electronics Laboratories declared war on Don Aston. First came an appeal of the 1987 California ruling. Then Premier slid past its former franchisor, Charles Michelson for rights to The Shadow. Then, using intermediaries, Premier ordered and received copies of The Shadow from the defendants...and Premier filed its lawsuits. According to a letter written by a Los Angeles attorney who handled Aston's trademark case, behind-the-scenes maneuvering came from a woman attorney who was later to file her appearance as counsel to Premier. She called Aston's trademark-case attorney, and said that [J. David Goldin] had demanded that the California [trademark] case be resolved before there can be any settlement of the Connecticut [Shadow] action. I advised her that [trademark case] was resolved and we had won and there was a reported decision. She said that it was up on appeal. I advised her that in my opinion the appeal would be unsuccessful. She nevertheless repeated her statement that [Goldin] demanded that the action in California be resolved, which was clearly an indication that we should grant them the rights which the court has so far found that they are not entitled to and then, and only then, would they discuss the settlement of the California action. ...In my opinion, this Connecticut action was not brought for any legitimate purpose to solve any legitimate grievance or prospective grievance by Premier against Aston. Rather, it was brought solely for the malicious purpose of harassing Aston and forcing him to give up what he has already won. As you well remember, when [Goldin] met with Mr. Aston a few months ago [1988] he opened the conversation by telling the Astons that he was there to talk them out of what they had won in court. One unmistakable feature of the letter above (and all other sources for this article) is that Premier's sole stockholder (according to the trademark -case complaint) is Jon Sonneborn...yet it is J. David Goldin whose name is almost invariably used. Goldin is believed to have sold his interest in Radio Yesteryear and Radiola, but an effort to confirm this from Sonneborn has gone unanswered. Don Aston flatly states The Shadow lawsuit is Premier's retribution for losing the first round in the trademark litigation. The behind-the-scenes effort to resolve this case, before settling The Shadow lawsuit, tends to support this. Other Shadow defendants say that another probable cause of the suit is to utterly crush the same hobbyist vendors with whom J. David Goldin had either traded or competed, in his earliest years of OTR program sales. Defendants (and, as events were to later show, Conde Nast) saw agreement in another area: despite offers of out- of-court settlement and even Conde Nast's offer to mediate the dispute, Premier had steadfastly refused to accept an end to its lawsuit. Aston says this was to keep the legal heat turn up on high, to force a trademark case resolution, while others saw it as skillful legal maneuvering to delay a final trial date being set...and whopping legal defense fees would do the rest. One such Premier maneuver required pro se [without attorney] answers from Shadow defendants, but once these were given, Premier refused to accept them... claimed the defendants were in default...obtained default judgements against them...and the defendants were forced to bear all costs in making a motion to vacate those default judgements. One defendant learned to his horror, that his personal attorney had been disbarred and had not filed a pro se answer at all. The defendants' group-attorney managed to get this default judgement vacated, too but this was conditioned upon that same defendant paying Premier over $11,000 in legal fees. Another maneuver: Charlie Garant had immediately surrendered his Shadow master tapes and the $64.50 made during that contested period, and while I was waiting for a reply, the lawyers filed a motion for default. Several Shadow defendants have tried to settle out of court with Premier, for real or imaginary damages, but Premier has refused. Meanwhile, $200/hour defense fees continue to mount. In Don Aston's words, Whoever has the most money wins. In fairness, however, Shadow defense has a proven track record in old time radio lawsuits: the same counsel which had successfully represented the late Arch Oboler and others, against J. David Goldin and Radio Yesteryear. The U.S. District Court now involved with The Shadow case had ruled against Goldin over Lights Out, according to The Federal Reporter, Second Series, August 1, 1983. An OTR Groundswell Soon after Burnham's Illustrated Press article, the Shadow case turned into an OTR groundswell. Carolyn and Joel Senter formed what is now believe to be the first-ever appeal among general hobbyists, for legal-defense contributions to aid collector/dealers. The OTR Defense Fund (4003 Clifton Ave., Cincinnati, OH 45220) issued a Hobby-wide history-making appeal for money to defend the same OTR collector/dealers some hobbyists continue to deprecate even today...against another commercial program vendor. The Senters said in effect that only a court could decide who was right or wrong in this issue. But the defendants deserved to be heard in court. Unfortunately, the price tag on due process can become very high! More help came from the 1990 Friends of Old Time Radio convention in Newark also breaking new ground by donating $500 the OTR Defense Fund which came directly from the convention fund. An additional $300 was collected from collectors attending the convention. Awarding the $500 was FOTR mainstay Jay Hickerson (Hello Again editor/publisher). Only days after FOTR Ô90, events jolted into high gear, when the OTR Defense Fund learned of the newest wrinkle in the on-going Shadow battle...the corporate reaction by the all-but-forgotten new owner of The Shadow property, Conde Nast Publications. One of the first steps for Premier to prove its case against the Shadow defendants required a document inspection, wherein attorneys for Premier, the defendants and Conde Nast met to examine copyright certificates Conde Nast holds for The Shadow. At that meeting, a Conde Nast attorney expressed concern about possible adverse publicity as a result of this case going against Ômom and pop' operations. This, indeed, was the raw meat which the OTR collectors had been clamoring for. The OTR Defense Fund swiftly contacted its network of benefactors, urging them to write Conde Nast board chairman Samuel I. Newhouse Jr., and company president Bernard Leser. The Senters asked writers to object to Premier having filed suit without first issuing a cease and desist letter to defendants, and to object to damage-demands amounting to 27 times any real damages which could have ensued from any infringements the defendants might have committed. Initially, more radical hobbyists were howling for an all-out boycott against Conde Nast Publications. One plan called for picketing publicity-shy franchise bookstores, local news media coverage, and then parlaying this into national publishing and advertising media trade publications. More direct pressure on CNP would come (others said) by simply not buying any of the company's magazines. Not including subscriptions-only Conde Nast Traveler, combined retail cover price of remaining CNP magazines sell for $24.40. Of this, some 40% is written off in trade discounts to entice retailers to stock the magazines, for an adjusted one-month total of $14.64. Multiplying by even half the 10,000 names on old time radio dealers' mailing lists, this totals $73,200 for one month and $878,400 for one year...not wildly different from what Premier wants from all Shadow defendants. The boycott fever against Conde Nast noticeably lessened in late December 1990, when Conde Nast brought out its own artillery (see CNP Steps In, below). Meanwhile, the more bloodthirsty OTR fans continued individual all-out boycott assaults against Radio Yesteryear, in a form of name brand recognition which the California trademark case had not had in mind. Also in late December, explosive new documentation and corroboration surfaced, on another Premier subsidiary, and its own heretofore unsung role in the war in the oxide trenches. The Sandy Hook Connection Sandy Hook Records, a second album subsidiary to Premier Electronics, has released dozens of LPs related to nostalgic music, radio broadcasts or movie soundtracks. Among them is Sandy Hook SH-#2110, entitled Connee Boswell & the Boswell Sisters. SH-#2110 states it is copyrighted in Sandy Hook Records' name. A convincing argument to the contrary is U.S. Copyright Office Form N-48483, registered in 1977, showing Connee Boswell and the Boswell Sisters On the Air was registered to Totem Records, one of three small-run LP labels operated by Shadow co-defendant, Larry F. Kiner. Sandy Hook Records also claimed copyright for its SH-#2021 as well: Jack Teagarden On the Air 1936- 1938. On May 13, 1980, the U.S. Library of Congress Reference and Bibliography section for Copyright Office records searches said this album was registered under SR-12-958, in 1978...to another Kiner LP label, Aircheck records. Other Sandy Hook titles claiming copyrights were: #2002 Bing Crosby On the Air #2003 Al Jolson On the Air #2016 Artie Shaw On the Air 1939-1940 #2020 Alice Faye On the Air 1932-2934 #2027 The Thirties Girl Bibliographer William A. Moore said a records search from 1978-1980 failed to disclose any separate registration for works identifiable as relating to Sandy Hook label under specific titles. Kiner claims ownership to all these albums and has produced a list of some 68 Sandy Hook titles (#2001-#2110 inclusive) showing 51 albums are identical in content to LPs issued by other small-run LP companies, including Hollywood Sound Stage, Sunbeam, Sountrak, Joyce, Take Two, Giants of Jazz, Pelican, and Star Tone. Kiner's own Totem, Aircheck, and Spokane labels account for 14 of the 51 titles in dispute. Independent corroboration of Kiner's listing comes from Sunbeam/Sountrak founder Alan A. Roberts of Van Nuys, CA (12 albums) and Hollywood Sound Stage founder Howard Goldberg of Flushing, NY (8 albums). All 34 albums these three sources say were first issued by themselves, turned up in Sandy Hook Records catalogs, and in album jackets bearing Sandy Hook copyright notices. Kiner writers, Most, if not all, of the Sandy Hook products were originated by someone else! Often, they even duplicate the artwork, simply removing logos, addresses, etc., and replacing with their own. In all cases the Sandy Hook records claimed a Ôcopyright,' and my research indicates that in all cases, none were issued. Both Roberts and Goldberg concur, with Roberts adding: It would be an easy matter to prove who brought them out first, and my editing was unique and [J. David Goldin] didn't bother to change any of that. Kiner adds he has tried for several years to force Sandy Hook Records to withdraw albums replicating his own, without success. At one point, he says, a lawyer for Sandy Hook Records told him that if he did not stop harassing Sandy Hook over what they termed his unfounded claims, that Sandy Hook would sue him. How come Premier/Sandy Hook/J.David Goldin/Jon Sonneborn group continue to sell and to list and to offer for sale my LPs that I have been complaining about? They've made no attempt to withdraw those LPs and apparently do not recognize my complaints or copyrights. What is the difference between the two? Kiner has now filed a copyright infringement suit of his own, against Premier Electronics and Jon Sonneborn. This countersuit was discussed years ago, Roberts said, between himself, Kiner, and Jim Bedoyan of Take Two records (whose Al Jolson album shows up as Sandy Hook SH-#2107 in Sandy Hook Records' list). Multiple sources for this article say this countersuit is not only long overdue, but also that Kiner's countersuit is now expected to be among the strongest Shadow defendants' group defense weapons. Even more devastating to Premier Electronics than allegations it too has infringed on copyrighted material (while refusing to settle its own case aimed at other infringers ) is the real impact of the newest wrinkle in this Shadow battle. Conde Nast Publications is also taking legal action against its own licensee. CNP Steps In Conde Nast filed an amended complaint and cross-claim on December 14, 1990 in U.S. District Court, District of Connecticut, seeking to become the sole plaintiff in Civil Case 89-135-WWE, the formal docket number for Donald L. Aston and now also the master docket number for all Shadow defendants Conde Nast Publications alleges that Premier Electronics Laboratories breached its Shadow licensing agreement, by failing to allow CNP to pursue any infringement claims on its own, before Premier brought its own legal guns out against the present defendants. This one almost seems like CNP was reading the OTR Defense Fund's letter before it was ever written. The November 1, 1988 agreement stipulated CNP had the exclusive right but not the obligation to sue infringers, for a 60 day period following the later of: (1) CNP's receipt of a notice from Radiola or from another source regarding any infringement or continuing infringement, or (2) CNP's sending a cease and desist letter. If CNP failed to take action, then Premier was allowed the right but not the obligation to commence its own legal action. The reason that Conde Nast had not sent cease and desist letters, CNP's complain says, is because Premier specifically instructed CNP not to send cease and desist letters to Aston's Adventures, The Golden Radio Library, Bob Burnham, Dick Judge, Carl Froelich Jr., Redmond Nostalgia Company, Radio's Past, Charlie Garant, Golden Age Radio, Stoneground Features and McCoy's Recording, Inc. ... In accordance with Premier's instructions, CNP did not send cease and desist letters to these persons. Thereafter, Premier commenced the subject litigation [against these defendants]. Not only did CNP not consent to this breach of the terms of paragraph 10 of the agreement, it vigorously protested Premier's action, but Premier has refused to cure its breach of the agreement. CNP's complaint added they were therefore denied the opportunity to amicably resolve all claims of alleged infringement of the licensed rights. (Emphasis added.) Conde Nast acknowledged that most of the defendants have made only limited sales of the infringing products at issue and have offered settlements including consent to injunctive relief and payment of damages. Although CNP believes these settlement offers are a reasonable basis upon which a negotiated amicable settlement could have been reached long ago, Premier characterizes the offers as grossly inadequate and has failed to negotiate reasonably. Premier has even refused CNP's counsel's offer to act as an intermediary in settling the actions. Conde Nast asked the court to first add CNP as plaintiff in this case, to protect its Shadow property in a more direct manner; to have Premier found to have breached its licensing agreement; then to be permanently enjoined from commencing litigation against any unauthorized persons selling The Shadow recordings or using the CNP-trademarked character likeness in any manner. Best of all: CNP asks that Premier be dismissed as a party from this lawsuit and that CNP be substituted as sole plaintiff herein. Not-So-Hasty Conclusions At stake here now is Premier Electronics Laboratories' own credibility, considering PEL's ongoing trademark battle with Don Aston (and the telephone call to resolve a trademark decision PEL had lost in court to Aston). Also at issue are 34 out of 51 disputed albums in Sandy Hook Records' listings for its SH-#2001 through #2110...some 14 albums having been issued by another Shadow co-defendant, Larry Kiner. Taken alone, Kiner's claim to copyright infringement might seem fairly weak. Confirmation from two other LP producers...and from the U.S. Copyright Office...bring an entirely new and stronger emphasis to this claim. In that context, new meaning can be read into a memorandum of law filed by Conde Nast in conjunction with its amended complaint and cross-claim: Based on what has transpired to date, it appears that Premier may not be pursuing the readily available settlements for reasons unrelated to the protection of CNP's copyright and trademark rights or the vindication of Premier's exclusive rights under the License Agreement. The memorandum of law does not mention the 1987 trademark case against Don Aston, or Larry Kiner's counterclaim against Sandy Hook's use of his LPs...but Conde Nast does mention how Premier has consistently refused to accept mediation and its two 1989 letters asking that CNP not send cease and desist letters, according to paragraph 10 of the agreement. In a sworn affidavit accompanying CNP's amended complaint, and its memorandum of law, CNP Editorial Business Manager William P. Rayner mentioned the background on why Conde Nast had complied with those two letters: CNP was given no warning as to what Premier's plans were; it was entirely possible Premier planned to sub-license these infringers or to suggest they be left alone because of the minimal extent of their infringement. Instead, Premier commenced litigation... It does not require a juris doctorate to see a measure of disgust held by Conde Nast Publications over the actions taken by its licensee. The evidence now in hand shows that CNP simply got sick and tired of all the legal delays in minimal cases which CNP felt could have been settled by simple cease and desist letters had Premier not asked them to refrain, and then filed its Shadow lawsuits. Throughout all documents filed, the phrase amicable settlement recurs so often that its serves as Conde Nast's litany of its own philosophy toward infringements. Another litany, this time from Shadow defendants: The Shadow radio series itself has been so widely traded that in-Hobby demand for that series has reached nearly rock-bottom levels. Yet Premier held fast to its demands for huge settlement figures from each defendant...even saying one defendant was in default, after sending them his total sales for that series during their licensing period, and his master tapes. Don Aston and Larry Kiner have presented credible reasons to show that Premier's Shadow lawsuit may well indeed have unseen motives particularly the effort to resolve Premier's trademark case, and Kiner's 14 albums issued by Sandy Hook Records. It does not help Premier's credibility when the U.S. Copyright Office cannot find Sandy Hook Records copyrights for the titles its album jackets stated were copyrighted in Sandy Hook's name. Nor can it help Premier's credibility when Jon Sonneborn won't even confirm J. David Goldin had sold Radio Yesteryear, Radiola, and/or any other former Goldin company to Premier. Conde Nast in turn displayed its own credibility by producing the copyright certificates for The Shadow, at the document inspection meeting which Premier had brought about by its lawsuits. It seems reasonable after Larry Kiner's claim and other statements made by veteran collector/dealers that Premier Electronics should now show copyright certificates of their own, for SH-#2001 through #2110 inclusive. Premier should also explain the motives for that refusal to settle The Shadow suit against Aston's Adventures, until the trademark suit is resolved. Premier should also explain how the prompt submission of Shadow master tapes and total proceeds of Shadow program sales during the contested period can constitute being in default. Possibly most importantly, Premier can gain maximum credibility by fully explaining the nature of its relationship to J. David Goldin. If Goldin did in fact sell Radio Yesteryear and Radio, then why was his name specified by the Aston trademark-case attorney when she called Aston's attorney? What had Goldin gone to California, to pursue this issue in 1988...three years after Premier filed the trademark suit? Why has Goldin's name (and not Jon Sonneborn's or Premier's) name been used by more than two dozen sources contacted for this article? Would Premier have filed its 1985 California lawsuit, had it not owned Goldin's former companies? Why then would Goldin show such interest in these lawsuits...unless he had an active role in helping to orchestrate them? Should that last part prove to be provably true, then we can further believer the collector/dealers are correct: that Goldin is going after those OTR vendors with whom he competed in his earliest days of selling programs...back in those days when Goldin himself withdrew The Shadow from his own catalog. Finally, the credibility of Premier's claim (through its Sandy Hook Records subsidiary) that SH #2001 through #2110 inclusive are copyrighted in Sandy Hook's name...while the U.S. Copyright Office states otherwise. The Library of Congress (which oversees copyrights) has a staff known internationally for their great pains to provide accurate, unbiased information in their reports. So if there are to be any money bets placed on this entire copyright discussion, the odds on Sandy Hook actually holding copyrights for its SH #2001-#2110 inclusive are precisely the same as the likelihood that a shimmering silver flying saucer will land in CNP president Bernard H. Leser's back-yard birdbath...whereupon little green men will disembark and request in flawless Queen's English that they be allowed the honour of marrying Mr. Leser's pet canary. Who will reply: Aaawwwwp! Polly wants a copyright! Conde Nast, after all, has shown its copyrights...all over a legal battle that might never have arisen, if not for Premier...a company Larry Kiner, Alan Roberts, Howard Goldberg, and the U.S. Copyright Office all say lack copyrights of its own. So now (at long and expensive last) isn't turnabout for Premier indeed fair play?