|
|
July 18 - August 2, 2004 |
![]() |
We're just back from an intensely enjoyable two weeks in Israel
with a group of 41, mostly families from Adat Shalom. Ascending
the atmosphere via British Air on the way to Israel were the Blum,
Dunn, Feder, Gorosh, Greenstein, Nevins, Portney, Supowit and
Scheele families. For most of the kids and many of the adults,
it was a first view of the Land, and we traveled extensively to
the west, north, east and south, experiencing the people, places
and history that make Israel a constant source of wonder for all
who love her. Having Lynn's parents with us was a great enhancement
for both our family and the entire group.
The flights with British Air via Heathrow were fine, though the
kosher meals made many of us consider becoming Hindu vegetarian
for the sake of the return trip. But all went smoothly, and our
first whiff of dry Israeli air mixed with jet fumes at Ben
Gurion Airport energized everyone to push through their exhaustion
and plunge right into the ocean of Israel. Indeed our first stop
at the Renaissance Hotel in Tel Aviv allowed us to jump
in the Mediterranean for a brief time before we dressed and began
our formal tour.
For the first time, I had made trip arrangements with an Israeli
company called Keshet: The Center for Educational Tourism in
Israel. Yitzhak Sokoloff had worked intensively with
me over the preceding six months to make this trip informative,
enjoyable and spiritually powerful. While we covered many of the
essential tourist sites and activities, there were also many unique
encounters with Israelis who take the ideal of creating a model
Jewish society in our ancient homeland as a personal challenge
and opportunity.
Essential to the success of our trip was the first rate staff
which Yitzhak assembled. Our tour educator (i.e. "guide")
was Danny Ehrlich, a Long-Island raised, YU educated, resident
of Efrat who spoke with erudition, sincerity, humility and humor
in a sweet Long Island accent that we all came to adore. Danny
is modern-Orthodox with an emphasis on Modern. He was very in-tune
with the tone I hoped to set for the group-unwaveringly devoted
to the people and religion of Israel, while open to historical
and social criticism in order to foster a more mature and durable
attachment to our Jewish identity. OK, so that was neither pithy
nor elegant, but you get the idea.
I wanted us to travel with a Tanakh (Hebrew Bible) and
we did indeed use its text, focusing largely on the book of Isaiah
since our two Shabbatot, Hazon and Nachamu, presented
the two components of rebuke and comfort which are an essential
part of the Jewish message.
Along with Danny, we had two stellar youth educators named Anat
Adler and Tali Meyerson. Both had extensive youth group
backgrounds (B'nai Akiva) and were far more than social counselors.
Whenever there was an opportunity, Tali and Anat would respectively
take out the younger and older kids for a song, game, dance, scavenger
hunt or deep discussion. This allowed the kids to bond very quickly
with each other, to get much more from the trip, and to allow
the adults to appreciate the depth of Danny's knowledge. It was
a thing of beauty to watch the kids interact-we had twelfth graders
playing with 4-5 year olds, girls braiding each other's hair,
boys climbing trees and walls and each other's backs, teens reading
to 7 year olds etc. Family.
Our guard, Harel Sharabi, quickly became an essential part
of the team, bonding with all of the kids, especially the two
youngest boys, Joey Greenstein and our Sam. We were all confident,
even when they took the little ones off for hours of wandering
in Tzfat, that the kids would be safe and happy. When we heard
that Harel was being reassigned mid-trip, both Danny and I howled
protests and he was soon returned for the duration.
Striking about our group was the good will and group commitment
of both adults and kids. This was not a cliquish bunch, and despite
exhaustion, everyone had a willing spirit, a high tolerance for
our fast pace, and a sense of adventure that made the trip a joy
for all. With Keshet's help, I had planned a mix of fun activities,
serious educational content and meaningful encounters with Israelis.
The trip started and ended with lighter activities, while Tisha
B'Av occupied the somber middle ground. The overall impact was
an excellent balance that worked well for our group.
Monday, July 19: Tel Aviv. After our refresher, we set out for Rabin Square, where we reflected on the dangerous fissions in Israeli society that boiled over on that tragic November night in 1995. Danny's take was that Rabin's initial plan of linking territorial withdrawal to Palestinian peacefulness was appropriate, but that the continuation of Israeli retreats in the face of Arab terror in 94-95 was a disaster. Yet, he also deplored the violent rhetoric and ultimately action that blossomed in the Orthodox community during that period, and spoke movingly later at Rabin's grave about this Israeli hero.We had a late dinner in the Yemenite Quarter, and then, fading fast, retreated to the hotel for a brief rest and an early departure.
On Tuesday, July 20, we zipped north towards our first
stop in Tzippori, the gem of an archeology park in the
Galilee. We toured for hours in the hot sun-perhaps more than
we needed to-but were able to explore the Mishnaic period with
its heady mix of Biblical, Judean and Greek influences reflected
in the art, architecture and literary texts that emerged 1,800
years ago.
After a boxed lunch we drove on around Haifa and up the coast
to Nahariya, a quiet coastal town just south of the border
with Lebanon. The Park Plaza hotel there was quite comfortable,
and we had a bit of time for swimming before heading out for a
late-afternoon bike ride through banana orchards over to the Achziv
coast. There were a few falls and scrapes along the way, and Sam
fell deeply asleep on the back of Lynn's bike, flopping around
like a rag doll as we rolled through the fields. Still, we arrived
in one piece for a delicious BBQ on the beach as the darkening
sky and stars made the sea glisten at our feet. I had thought
we would arrive at Rosh HaNikra, the massive barrier of
grottoes at the Lebanese border, at sunset, but it was already
dark when we descended by cable car. The pounding waves were impressive,
and then Anat and Tali put on a hysterical play to finish a fun
day.
Wednesday, July 21, we headed east just below the Lebanese
border (which had flared up with a sniper shooting two Israeli
soldiers the day before) all the way to the Golan Heights.
We started our touring at Mitzpeh Gadot, the famous Syrian
stage for attacks on Northern Israel. Danny told the Eli Cohen
story, and the kids explored the bunkers. Then we continued up
and east to Mount Bental, the Israeli controlled bunker
that overlooks Syria and was the site of some of the 1973 tank
battles that rattled Israel to its core.
Down from the mountain, we headed to Katzrin for a fend-for-yourself
lunch and shopping stop, then on to Gamla to watch the
vultures soar and get acquainted with Josephus and the fall of
this fortress to Rome. Afterwards we headed to the Ramot
section of the Golan, where off-road jeeps led us on a bouncing
exploration of the Golan from heights down to marsh land. In the
evening, we wandered about Tiberias, meeting up with some
of the teens as well as a bunch of rabbi friends-Jeremy Kalmanofsky,
Arnie Sleutelberg and Eric Yanoff. Our hotel was the rustic youth
hostel called Poriah, way up the slope over the Kinneret.
It was spartan but adequate for our few hours of rest.
Thursday, July 22, we left early again up to the Lebanese
border, arriving at the ancient synagogue of Bar-Am. This
was the first time the entire group davened together (we had optional
minyan each morning). Madeleine Blum, Jordan Supowit and Jamie
Gorosh each read from Parshat Devarim-after a quick
nosh, we headed even closer to the border, to the Kibbutz called
Malkiyah.
This was a surreal experience. Farmer Eitan offered us crunchy
apples in his orchard, then pointed up the hill towering over
our heads to the guard tower and said, "this is Hizballah."
None of us expected to be quite this close to an active and frankly
dangerous border. Apparently he felt quite confident though, and
even enjoyed waving a tourist bus in the faces of this violent
enemy. We sauntered over to the adjacent Turmous (lupine)
base, a small but active Givati outpost which monitors and when
necessary crosses the border. We felt privileged to visit such
a sensitive frontier base, but it was a sober reminder of the
active state of hostilities along the northern border.
After lunch in the Kiryat Shmoneh "Kanyon" or
mall, we headed for our "kayak" or rafting experience
on the Hatzbani tributary of the Jordan R. I think
I've done this river route 3 times before, but it was tremendous
fun, splashing everyone, jumping in the river and even enjoying
a little rapids at the end. What a varied day-from the sacred
to the militant to the commercial to the adventurous-it wouldn't
be complete without a walking tour of Tzfat, a review of
the Kabbalistic traditions that emerged there, and an outstanding
dinner on a private rooftop overlooking Mt. Meron. We arrived
back at Poriah exhausted and yet enthralled by the day.
Friday, July 23 Danny and I had mercy and let the group
sleep a bit later (7:30) before davening and checking out. We
went to Mt. Arbel with its magnificent cliff-top views,
and then started our ride all the way to Jerusalem. Using the
new Highway #6, we made decent time and enjoyed a first view of
the old city from Mt. Scopus. We went to the Kotel
for a pre-Shabbat visit, avoiding the throngs later on Friday
night. Then it was on to the King Solomon Hotel to prepare for
Shabbat. Our family was treated to a suite on the top floor (14)
with magnificent views of the entire city.
Jerusalem was also the time for a reunion with my parents, Michael
and Phyllis Nevins, who were visiting our Tel Aviv cousins and
joining in Aunt Rina's surprise 70th birthday party. Rina and
her whole crew joined us for Shabbat dinner at the hotel, and
my parents stuck with us through Tisha B'Av on Tuesday. For services,
I took the group down to my favorite garden (bustan) in
the park above Yemin Moshe for a private Kabbalat Shabbat
service. It was a perfect night and the group really came together
in appreciating the gifts of Israel, Jerusalem and Shabbat itself.
This was one of the trip highlights for me.
Shabbat Chazon, July 24. A hardy core walked early with me to Emek Refaim Street where we joined with Shirah Chadasha, a cutting edge feminist-Orthodox singing groovy congregation. My friend Alick Isaacs was gabbai, which won me hagbah (no easy feat with the mechitzah wire cutting over the Torah table). It was fun to see a lot of Jerusalem-based friends in the courtyard. Other members of our group walked to the Conservative Center or the Great Synagogue. Afterwards, we had a great picnic lunch joined by Tami Elliot, our family educator who has just started at HUC. A lazy afternoon by the pool was followed with games for the kids and Torah study with me back in the park, and then a beautiful havdalah up on our mirpeset (balcony). Lynn and I were too tired to eat out-the four grandparents got to take our kids for dinner.
Sunday, July 25 was our day for serious exploration of the Old City. Starting on Mt. Zion, Danny reviewed the 1948-1967 experience and impressed upon us the difficulty of dividing the city in any rational way. We walked back alleys, ascended onto rooftops, and finally found our way to the "broad wall" built in the time of King Hezekiah (701 BCE) who mysteriously fended off the Assyrian King Sanecherib, just as (first) Isaiah had predicted. After lunch in the Rova (Jewish Quarter) we walked down to the City of David to explore Warren's Shaft and walk the famous water tunnel. Here we hit a crisis, as the three youngest boys refused to plunge into the dark wet hole in the ground. Can't really blame them, but I wound up walking back up the hill with Tracye Blum and three little guys until the group rejoined us. The bus took everyone back to the hotel, but Lynn, the kids and I grabbed a cab and made an express visit to our friends Alick and Shuli Isaacs and their 4 kids. It was a wonderful 45 minute visit after which we had to herd the group back to the old city to tour the Kotel tunnels. While I always love that tour, I pulled out early and jogged all the way back to the Hartman Insitute, where Alick had tipped me off about a new one man play to be acted by the author Robbie Greenglass. Called "Situation" it told the story of a British immigrant who comes too close for comfort to a suicide bombing and yet still wants to apply to become a "Shaliach Aliyah" or immigration advocate for Israel. Meanwhile, Jerusalem was the final stage of a huge human chain linking the Gaza settlements to the capital-it was a dramatic statement of support for the settlers, undermining the argument that they can be uprooted without significant upheaval in Israeli society.
Monday, July 26. For shacharit, we all headed back down
to the Kotel, this time visiting Robinson's Arch
for another Torah service. I find it very emotional to pray right
next to a pile of rubble left by the Temple walls. Our readers
were Victoria Greenstein, Becca Portney and Alex Feder and
the service went very well despite everyone's apparent exhaustion.
By the time we got to the United Synagogue Yeshiva we were
off schedule, which was a shame since Rabbi Daniel Goldfarb
had prepared an excellent shiur (class) for us. My parents
joined us again, and we all enjoyed the rest of the day's visits.
First, to Malei Adumim, we heard from Yitzhak Sokoloff
a detailed account of the emigration of Ethiopian Jews to Israel.
Then we divided in two and visited with Ethiopian families to
learn their own personal stories. Our own host took down a massive
mural of village life in Ethiopia, explaining to us what they
left behind. While their journey was extremely difficult and tragic,
it is apparent that they have claimed a wonderful stake in Israeli
society "lamrot hakol" in spite of everything.
Next we traveled down the road to the small community of Nofei
Prat, where Lynn's good friend Magi Aharoni lives with
her family. I wanted our group to visit a "settlement"
to see that these people were not wild-eyed, gun-toting extremists,
but idealistic Israelis eager to settle the land. This visit was
also too short, but I could see members of our group filled with
respect and even envy for the tight community of Jews living there
on the dramatic edge of the desert.
We broke for a quick dinner, and then headed down to the Haas
Promenade for our reading of Lamentations (Eicha).
Fortunately, we found a secluded spot that was just right for
our group. Looking north towards the remnants of ancient Jerusalem,
we read of her destruction in the plaintive and stirring melody
of lament. Rabbi Jonathan Berkun joined us and chanted
Chapter 3. In our group, Shana Supowit, our guide Danny,
my mother and I all read, and then we shared modern reflections
upon tragedy and sacrifice in Jewish life. Thousands of people
were there, and while the sorrow was palpable, so too was the
hopefulness of seeing the Jewish people remember its past and
resolve to build a better future.
Tuesday, July 27. Several of us walked early to the
Conservative Synagogue on Agron Street for the traditional
Tisha B'Av liturgy. Skipping breakfast, we joined with
the group in dropping the younger kids at the Biblical Zoo
(where they played for hours) and then proceeding to Yad VaShem.
Danny was outstanding in his presentation of the development of
this catastrophe-he added enough drama to drive home the enormity
of the loss. I saw my parents off, & then lingered in the
Valley of Communities, getting far more from this place than usual.
I found the Felshtyn and Dabrowa sections and thought about those
relatives on Mom and Dad's sides who never made it out of Europe.
While Danny guided the adults, Tali did a wonderful job with the
teens-she is a sophisticated educator and soon had them debating
which date was most appropriate for Yom HaShoah-Kristallnacht,
Wansee, Tisha B'Av etc. I had great admiration for her work.
Next we visited Mt. Herzl, taking time to appreciate the
vision of Theodore Herzl as well as of Yitzhak Rabin. By now it
was very hot, and even those not fasting were wilting in the sun,
but it was still a moving experience for me. In the late afternoon,
I had an excellent study session on the "Yad VaShem"
haftarah which we read at that time. Our participants were so
bright and interested that I felt the more ambitious academic
goals of our mission were as successful as the lighter parts of
the tour.
Wednesday, July 28, our mood lifted as we headed out
of Jerusalem and down to Abu Gosh, an Arab village with
a history of friendship for Israel. On the Federation visit in
April, I had met a remarkable Benedictine monk named Olivier who
showed us the monastery and sang Gregorian chant with an Israeli
police officer named Shuki. Unfortunately, Shuki couldn't join
us, but we had a wonderful visit with Olivier, who positively
glowed in our presence. Members of our group were deeply moved
by the visit that added another complex ingredient to our portrait
of Israel.
On to Beit Guvrin, the popular archeological dig, we headed
underground and pulled pottery from the earth. Escaping from the
heat and sun, we spelunked around narrow caves, trying to imagine
the Bar Kokhba rebels hiding from their Roman oppressors. Then
lunch and down to the desert for our visit Mitzpe Ramon,
the town overlooking Machtesh Ramon, the dramatic crater
(or geological formation) in the dessert. We stayed in a lovely
hotel called Pundak Ramon which featured decent apartments, a
nice pool, and fantastic cuisine. After a banquet dinner
in which I gave certificates to the B'nai Mitzvah, we took the
bus out to a cliff over the crater and watched the stars emerge
as winds raced across the desert.
Thursday, July 29, some woke before dawn to watch the sun rise over the crater. After breakfast we all went back to the cliff and started rapelling down the side. It was amazing to watch even little kids like Leora (7) scrambling down the cliff like little spiders. Afterwards, we drove deeper into the crater to observe the unique colors of sand and stone, then headed up to Sdei Boker, the dramatic burial spot of David and Paula Ben Gurion. Little ibexes wandered the site, munching on leaves and giving us a greater appreciation of the "Old Man's" beloved Negev. From there we drove to Yerucham, on of the poorest towns in Israel, for another gourmet meal served by local Moroccan families in their homes. We learned about the "BaMidbar" project which seeks to unite the desert communities in love for the Torah and people of Israel. Finally, we drove across to Mamshit, our Beduin encampment where we rode camels across the desert hills. It was dusty, windy and hot in the desert. Still, everyone was a good sport about the open dining and bed-rolled-tents. For a while, anyway! Most had trouble sleeping, especially those who learned that a fellow guest from the Camp Ramah group was stung by a scorpion after midnight.
Friday, July 30. We didn't have much time to fret, though,
since we awoke at 3:30 and headed off towards the Arad
side of Massada. The drive was longer than expected, and
we reached the Roman ramp just as the sun cleared the cliffs at
6 AM. It was lovely, but the temperature sure climbed quickly.
We had a short but powerful tefillah, then Danny began
a stimulating tour. He debunked the Josephean account of mass
suicide, arguing that this was a self-serving tale spun by Josephus,
which has been undermined by archeological findings. Danny was
quite convincing, and the kids were also absorbed by Anat and
Tali's skilful guiding.
Down by cable car, we headed off to Ein Gedi-the last thing
I wanted was another hike, but it was lovely up by the waterfall,
where the kids promptly commenced an algae war, pelting each other
with green slime. That I tolerated pretty well, but I was in a
funk by the time we reached the Dead Sea. The temperature
hovered around 108, and my internal thermostat felt about the
same. We escaped as quickly as possible and returned towards Jerusalem
for our final Shabbat.
Shabbat Nachamu, July 31. Fortunately, we had arranged for Lynn and the kids to spend Shabbat with Magi in Nofei Prat while the rest of us moved into the beautiful Kibbutz Ramat Rachel. This allowed me to nurse my bronchitis, get some antibiotics from Steve Portney, and do the minimum amount of activity possible for me on a Shabbat. This meant giving a Dvar Torah to the 100+ teens who were finishing their mission in high spirits and emotional excess, and then leading a study session of Nachamu after lunch, and another study session with our group in the late afternoon. It was great to see our teens so full of excitement and to share a small part of their experience. After Havdalah, everyone fanned out in the city for a delicious meal-there is no shortage of fine restaurants in Israel, and the people are back in the streets and cafes.
Sunday, August 1. Keshet was eager for us to learn about
as many idealistic Israelis as possible, and this final day of
our trip was no different. We started at Yad LeKashish,
the Lifeline for the Elderly. Here we learned about the workshops
where Jerusalem's senior citizens can come to create beautiful
art, earn money and retain their dignity into old age. We also
shopped in the wonderful gift shop. Then it was on to the neighborhood
of Ir Ganim, which had been one of the poorest and most
crime-ridden sectors of the city. An urban Kibbutz called Reishit
set up their community amidst the drug dealers and other thugs,
and gradually helped reclaim the parks, apartment blocks and schools
for decent people. We planted not trees but medicinal herbs in
the lovely park at Ir Ganim, adding our efforts to help
heal the people of Israel.
Then it was time to shop, swim and slide in the wonderful Ramat
Rachel pool and begin to pack. For our final banquet, Tali
and Anat had prepared the kids to perform some fun skits. Yitzhak's
wife Ruti and daughter performed klezmer music for us, and their
son Chaim made a power-point slide show. We ate, danced and reflected
upon the incredible experience of traveling in Israel together
as families and as a family.
Conclusion
All endings are difficult. Rising early to catch our flight,
hugging our Israeli staff goodbye, and flying off to England and
America was no easy task. Yet the 41 adventurers who joined this
trip took with us a intense love of Israel-both the land and the
people. We realized yet again that this remarkable country is
not the object of pity or charity but an inspiration and role
model for what an idealistic and determined people can accomplish.