April 5, 2004 Update: All VGA Planets games at Madkestrel's Universe are now CLOSED. Players voted unanimously to stop the two remaining games due to frustration and disgust with the software. Needless to say, no more games will be opening.

This is the former home of MadKestrel's VGA Planets 4 Universe. Now, it's not.

I used to host VGA Planets 4 games here. I don't anymore. I used to have help files (that I wrote myself) and useful links for players here. I don't have those anymore either. I used to enjoy playing VGA Planets. Now, VGA Planets just gives me a mammoth headache.

After a year of trying to learn, host and teach VGA Planets 4, I'm throwing in the proverbial towel. What a mammoth disappointment this game turned out to be! I play games to have FUN, and VGA Planets V4 is definitely NOT fun. It is a programming disaster, waiting for it's chance to waste your time and sanity.

Yes, VGA Planets 4 is still in beta test, but it appears to be in a developmental Black Hole. Changes (I can't say "improvements"), have no single direction or goal, and after nearly four years, there is still no single part of the game that is finished. The author keeps "tweaking" both races and program apparently based on personal whim and bias. He keeps taking payment and promising beta buyers registered versions when the game is in "full release".

What exactly are people buying in this beta release? Active players of this game all pretty much agree that the eleven original "Tim races" are far more powerful that the newer "3rd party" races that the software author has allowed other people to "contribute". Add to that, the "undocumented features" (read: bugs, and there are dozens, if not hundreds) present in the game favor certain races over others. But that doesn't really matter, because he's changing the game all the time, expecting players who have invested dozens, if not hundreds of hours setting up a strategy, to suddenly find whole fleets utterly stripped of their power and useless. Ships with scanners of 350 lights years, with all scanners turned on are still unable to scan an enemy vessel at 20 light years. And this pathetic effect is INTENDED to be a part of the playing experience of VGA Planets 4.

In one particular MadKestrel's Universe game (which was eventually cancelled due to imbalance), we had some problems with the author's "favored race". As host, I tried steps to bring the game back into some semblance of balance, but the more I learned about the game, the more I learned this was not an achievable goal. Read about it here.

The most stable race, against which all others are judged, "The Feds" are still changed on a regular basis: This quoted from a 3rd Party Race Strategy Hint file (note the dates):

And this race is the stable Benchmark against which the strength of other races are judged!!! (?) They've been in the game for FOUR YEARS! And remember, the race is supposed to be peaceful, and has additional racial advantages appropriate to a peaceful race.

The programmer of VGA Planets 4 is Tim Wisseman, whose webpage claims that 64,000 copies of his game have been sold worldwide. Of those people, I'd guess that about 63,000 have given up the game out of sheer frustration, because no more than a few hundred individuals appear to be playing on the few sites left on the net that host VGA Planets games of any version. At the time of this writing, there are ten sites on the VGAP 4 webring, Of these ten, one is a duplicate that is no longer functioning, one hosts only V3, and of the remaining eight, only three of these appear to be hosting any V4 games at all, the rest are on hold for some reason or another. Yeah, that counts this site too.

Here's a bit of information for anyone considering purchasing this piece of trash. At about the same time as Aaron Hall released Space Empires II (another 4X space wargame) in 1993, VGA Planets (v2 for DOS) appeared around the net. I'm not saying one or the other came first, but the interface for both games looked amazingly similar. VGA Planets used 11 races (all taken from Star Trek, Star Wars and Battlestar Galactica, and used without license) and combined these various approaches to futuristic technologies and into a single, somewhat awkward but enjoyable game that was ridden with bugs. (Most games bombed out completely around turn 65.)

Space Empires used their own unique races in a more stable technological environment and also enjoyed a large and enthusiastic following. The VGA Planets website doesn't have a history file, or a known bug list. Space Empires Malfador Machinations has both, so comparisons are difficult, but both games had a Version 3 that looked very similar to their own respective V2s. Both games continued to grow in popularity.

Currently both VGA Planets and Space Empires have a Version 4. But Malfador Machinations Space Empires IV has been in full public (finished) release since July of 2000, approximately the same time as VGA Planet V4 was released in Beta test. And Malfador Machination's Space Empires IV has a completely new look. Oddly enough, so does VGA Planets 4. And if you dare to look at both, they again bear a striking resemblance!

There is more: Both game's online documentation is not only in the same format, it's in the same colors! Space Empires III had different ground units, ministers and different base buildings, so it seems logical to me that these would translate well into the new version. They did. VGA Planets 3 had none of these, but VGA Planets 4 has them all. What am I insinuating? That Tim Wisseman hasn't ever had an original idea in his life and that, based on his plagiarism of copyrighted properties, VGA Planets v4 will never see public release. Not with artwork like this!

In short, VGA Planets 4 is a "formula victory" game that has been plagiarized from the work of others - races are so unbalanced that if players follow prescribed strategies, the winner of a game can be predicted based upon number of players and races existing in a game. The net fan-boys who play and support this game and help to write the formulas for victory pretty much agree that if you don't play in a specific way, you'll not only loose, you are stupid. Combine the playing populace's attitude with the software author's personal bias toward his favorite races and you have a travesty, not a game worth wasting your time on.

That's just not the kind of game that I want to waste my time on, and I certainly refuse to "Host" such idiocy. To that end, I have closed all open VGA Planets games and upon completion of the two games in progress, will delete the VGA Planets (all versions) from my hard drive and never again waste my time on it.

Personally, I want to play a game that is an intriguing strategy challenge, in which the player with the best strategy is the winner. VGA Planets 4 is not that game. VGA Planets 4 does not reward good strategy, it rewards those who best know how to manipulate the many bugs that are intended to be a part of the game. Note that a comprehensive list of these bugs is not available anywhere on the net, only certain people have access to such a list.

I just can't believe that with the current state of VGA Planets, the game will ever change enough to be fun to play again. My 'play time' is limited and I just don't feel like wasting it on a game that is Lost in Space with engines and life support failing.

On a positive note, I have changed my strategy game of choice to Space Empires IV. My husband and son have changed as well, and many of our friends will be following us in this change. If you want to play a challenging game that is already all that VGA Planets aspires to be, but never will, check out:

Malfador Machinations Space Empires IV

You'll find that it not only is it FINISHED, it works as advertised!

There is a free downloadable demo, with a tutorial! You'll find that the interface is organized and easy to use, unlike the unmanageable VGAP interface (even VGAP fans call it "unfriendly"). Giving orders to ships and units in SEIV is fast and easy - accomplished from master lists that don't even exist in VGAP. (VGAP ground units can't really be ordered, they sort of perform by whim and don't work the way they are supposed to do.) Space Empires is completely configurable, with a competent AI and battle simulator. (In VGAP there is no AI, and the battle simulator is written by a dedicated 3rd party.) SEIV can be played against the computer, via email or by TCP-IP (including LAN) and you can even add your own races! (No more waiting 3-6 years for Tim to approve yours - oh yeah, he's stopped approving new races to concentrate his efforts on making the basic program even worse!)

All this for a price that is only a few dollars more than the beta of VGA Planets!

VGA Planets vs. Space Empires IV: It's like choosing between having a migraine and finding $50 laying on the sidewalk. Really, there is that much difference.

Of course, that choice is yours to make.

Transporter logs indicate that you are life-form:
to dock at this station.