Editorial: Petersburg and the Federal Government

    The failings of the Federal government are all to apparent at Petersburg, Virginia.  The failings of the Union army at Petersburg are amazing, but the bumbling did not end in 1865.  

     Recently, the park service made plans to move the visitors center from Petersburg to City Point, a supply area several miles from the actual fields of battle.  Undoubtedly this is an important historic location, but what could be the reasoning behind this?  This was a complete puzzle to me until I learned what park service "Director for Cultural Resources Stewardship" Kate Stevens said in 1999.  She said, and I quote, "I do not want to hear about battles when I go to a Civil War park. I am not really interested in battles."  She was refering to the controversial new policy of interpreting the causes of the war at battlefields, but even before this shocking statement visitors have become accustomed to battlefield interpretation at an early elementary school level.  Perhaps worse, park officials have even testified before Congress that they did not want additional land because they don't have the money to maintain what they have.   

     The people of Petersburg greatly appreciated the actions of their fellow citizens in the repulse of Union troops on June 9, 1864, and commemorated the event each year.  This was the inspiration behind the national Memorial Day holiday.  The land on which this battle was fought, which is also where Union troops attacked Fort Mahone during the April 2, 1865 assault, is now completely lost to development.  Diners at the McDonalds can stare across the road to the stone markers commemorating the battle, but there is nothing else to see.  This is just one of many sites permanently lost to development.  

     In fact, much of the area of the siege has been lost, and the park service does not adequately interpret what is preserved.  Additionally, taxpayers, that is the real owners of the park, have to fork over $3 or $4 dollars for the "privilege" of visiting the park.  (Isn't a privilege just a right the government has stolen from the people then given back?)  In exchange for paying to see their own property, visitors endure minimal or nonexistent interpretation.  Battery 5 of June 15, 1864 fame is conveniently located near the visitors center, perhaps too conveniently.  For some unexplained reason some or most of the Confederate fortifications no longer exist and are marked by an unmowed strip, which passes through the parking lot.  The site of Union artillery positions on June 15th is on the Fort Lee army base.  The site of the decisive breakthrough is somewhere in the woods with no trail or marking that I could find, and further down the road there are unusual yet uninterpreted earthworks.  Anyone hoping to see the scene of the June 16th and 17th fighting had better be ready to walk.  What appears on the topo map as a road through much of the area has been blocked off and bicycles, which would be a logical form of transport on such trails, have been banned.  The topo map also shows a trailer park on part of the land.  The site of the disastrous attack of the 1st Maine Heavy Artillery on June 18th seems to be preserved, but since the park service signs lack specific information about the attack, who knows?   The area of the Union IX Corps attacks on June 18th is completely unmarked - You are on your own.  During this attack, Union troops plunged into a railroad cut only to be enfiladed with cannon.  I would think that people might want to see where this and other such events happened, but the park service must not think so.  The nearby events of the Battle of the Crater are covered, but nothing else.  A couple of mysterious trails intersect the road near the Taylor House ruins, but there is nothing to indicate where they are going and what you might see.    I believe in going off the beaten path, and as a result, I picked over 20 ticks off my body after visiting the park without having seen all I wanted to.  Further, most of  the area of the June 18th V Corps attack is on or across the interstate highway, basically inaccessible.

          Most park employees are excellent and dedicated, and I may be unfairly picking on the Petersburg park.  My ranting is not an attack on dedicated employees, but on the system.  So what exactly is my point?  If saving and interpreting battlefields is important to you, don't leave it up to the government.  Even though this is the government's job, its record speaks for itself.  We must support preservation organizations or lose our history forever. 


Back to Civil War Virtual Battlefield Tours