Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web: Message Board

Return to Topics
|
Post a reply/new message
|
Return to Web Page

Post a reply/new message

Topic: Attention: Tim Spalding

Started by Richard Leveson on 1/11/02, 8:48 AM


Subject

Attention: Tim Spalding

Name

Richard Leveson ([email protected])

Writen

1/11/02, 8:48 AM

Link

http://burton.richardleveson.com

Hello Tim: There seems to be a problem posting here in that messages get cut off - we have so little traffic here now that each one is important! Can we also fix the "%3B"!!


Subject

Attention me!

Name

Tim ([email protected])

Writen

1/11/02, 10:27 PM

Link

Isidore of Seville

That got my attention. Getting deep into the PERL this weekend. Thanks for keeping up the chat, while I napped.


Subject

Burton's Embellishments

Name

JOHN ([email protected])

Writen

1/14/02, 5:37 PM

For a man who had seen and done so much, I have always wondered about Sir Richard's apparent tendency to boast, pose and at times, I suspect, lie. Why the need to shock or pretend to be more/darker than his own extraordinary self? Was he playing to the gallery because of some personal deficiency? Was he in part playing the devil because this was the role his many enemies and detractors caste him in - give a dog a bad name, etc. You can't psychoanalyse the dead. Indeed you can only get the merest glimpses of their natures from such evidence as survives. But this question exercises me a lot when I think about him. Any views/perspectives?


Subject

Burton's Embelishments

Name

Richard Leveson ([email protected])

Writen

1/31/02, 9:44 AM

Link

http://burton.richardleveson.com/Comments1.html

I think any biography which doesn't give us a character portrait is essentially a failure. Likewise, any biography which bases a character portrait on uncertain ground is doomed. When a biographer makes a statement, it has to be substantiated and cannot be loose conjecture.

As I've written in my web page essay, Burton is an especially tough subject because Isabel destroyed huge amounts of source material in order for her romanticized view to be the prevalent one. I'd count her "Life" as a failure biographically - yet it contains a rich store of facts, some credible some not.

How do we draw out a character portrait without to some degree trying to psychoanalyze? Brodie hypothesized that Burton was latterly a sexual failure%3B McLynn carried such conjecture to absurdity by connecting Burton sexually with a monkey, and perhaps, trying to counteract such unsound assertions, Lovell states there is no evidence to support Burton having had homosexual tendencies, which is not the case. I think the attempts to "psychoanalyze" Burton have been pretty unsuccessful.

What we are able to observe is that Burton struggled for recognition and never achieved it, that this caused him to become deeply embittered, that he was too open with his opinions for his own good and that he affected this terrifying persona wherein he would at times stretch the truth to obtain a shock effect. And such behaviour demands an explanation of every biographer - in fact I think it is the key to understanding Burton's character - yet it has never been properly addressed. Now we can only do it by trying to "get into his head"!


Post a new message

Name

Email

Subject

Message

Optional Link URL

(Link Title)

This message is part of the message board for Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web, a web guide and directory to the African explorer, travel writer and translator of the Arabian Nights and the Kama Sutra.